Quantcast

Best 35mm DM stem?

Gary

"S" is for "neo-luddite"
Aug 27, 2002
7,649
5,562
UK
Has CRC finally run out of Funn Full On bars?
yeah. in 25.4 they have.

If you ever clean out your hole. I'd definitely buy them. (I run one of CRCs last batch of 710 full-on's on one of my hardtails).
 

Mo(n)arch

Turbo Monkey
Dec 27, 2010
4,441
1,422
Italy/south Tyrol
Deity uses 7075 T3 aluminium but no 35mm stem - yet.
Their stuff is light.
Didn't Brendog say something of a new bar and stem in the last team video?
 

kickstand

Turbo Monkey
Sep 18, 2009
3,441
392
Fenton, MI
Great, thanks for the update. Any pics of the combo? Do the front bolts take a 4mm or 5mm key?
Wife's Easton for reference, as you can see the "clamp" itself is similar in width to the ANVL, but WHERE it clamps to the bars is wider than the ANVL. Running a small stem spacer under her stem so we can keep the bars out of the compression adjust on the 40. She is running in the 40 or 45 mm reach (can't recall but its the shorter choice)




Pics of my ANVL stem and bar combo.









All of the bolts on the ANVL Stem are 5mm Allens, both the clamps and the bolts that go into the crown.
 

4130biker

PM me about Tantrum Cycles!
May 24, 2007
3,884
450
@Gary I'm running a fresh set of 750 funn full on bars on my hardtail- I love these bars- wish they didn't stop making them. Machined some spacers to fit a stem that's stiffer than those old Thomsons... Oh, hey, wanna buy a 50 OR a 70mm 25.4 Thomson stem? :brows:
image.jpeg

Edit: please excuse the cable rats nest. Stuck with a lockout lever if I want any compression adjust on this Reba fork :/
Edit: sorry for the derail Udi!
 

Gary

"S" is for "neo-luddite"
Aug 27, 2002
7,649
5,562
UK
Other than looks I was never a huge fan of
those old Thomsons
. sorry dude. Plus I run a 40mm stem on my HT. DM on DH bike.
Thanks for keeping me in mind tho.

@Udi's gotta be used to this shit by now. There's a wee messaging system up in the top right so we don't bother him. But where's the fun in that? ;)

Oh... and if you really want one less noodle flailing around your bars. use a short section of derailleur cable to pinch the comp adjuster in the position you want it on the Reba. You don't actually adjust compression damping or bother with lockout on a Hardtail. Do you? :/
 

Mo(n)arch

Turbo Monkey
Dec 27, 2010
4,441
1,422
Italy/south Tyrol
Buy a mill! Buy an 7075 aluminium block! Problem solved. Maybe text @kazlx ?
Monkey stems is what we need!

The candy stem looks mint. Still not sold on the slide-on design though.

Maybe I should use my SolidWorks license for something useful just once.:think:
 
Last edited:

Udi

RM Chief Ornithologist
Mar 14, 2005
4,915
1,200
These guys claim they can make a DM stem for 35mm bars at barely 100g...
Wrong length, no material specified, no width offset so clamp stance is narrow, and seen one day of testing.

I think they have a real chance at winning the Tantrum graphic design competition though...
 

Kanye West

220# bag of hacktastic
Aug 31, 2006
3,741
473
Buy a mill! Buy an 7075 aluminium block! Problem solved. Maybe text @kazlx ?
Monkey stems is what we need!

The candy stem looks mint. Still not sold on the slide-on design though.

Maybe I should use my SolidWorks license for something useful just once.:think:
I machined my own stem a long time ago in undergrad. It was a PITA honestly. I wouldn't do it again. Mostly getting the bar bore smooth and correct in a manual mill is a real bitch.

Easy enough to design however and easy to do in a CNC with a Z-axis surfacing cut for the bar bore.

At the moment I'm designing a Scott's steering damper sub-mount setup for Gemini/sasquatch that gives a custom reach for his dirt bike.
 

kidwoo

Artisanal Tweet Curator
Take a look at their website and see what name they've come up with for their grips...

http://www.candyray.com/

"wife beaters?"

Sweet. I'd totally trust a 100g stem from those guys. The only stem I've ever seen truly broken (as in separated bar) is an enve stem, but I'd bet that's a good candidate just based on their website.

They're in poland, so @norbar needs to step up and explain ;)
 

canadmos

Cake Tease
May 29, 2011
20,502
19,506
Canaderp
"wife beaters?"

Sweet. I'd totally trust a 100g stem from those guys. The only stem I've ever seen truly broken (as in separated bar) is an enve stem, but I'd bet that's a good candidate just based on their website.

They're in poland, so @norbar needs to step up and explain ;)
Did they also spell their own company name wrong on the bottom of their website? Fack...
 

kazlx

Patches O'Houlihan
Aug 7, 2006
6,985
1,957
Tustin, CA
I machined my own stem a long time ago in undergrad. It was a PITA honestly. I wouldn't do it again. Mostly getting the bar bore smooth and correct in a manual mill is a real bitch.

Easy enough to design however and easy to do in a CNC with a Z-axis surfacing cut for the bar bore.

At the moment I'm designing a Scott's steering damper sub-mount setup for Gemini/sasquatch that gives a custom reach for his dirt bike.
My buddy has a Sunnen Hone at the shop. Would be easy to cut them like 1/2 thou small and hone them to size on a fixture.
 
Last edited:

Kanye West

220# bag of hacktastic
Aug 31, 2006
3,741
473
If any of you cad monkies want to draw up something, I could probably work on getting them made.
I'll model/detail something next week if someone has requirements for something that isn't already on the market.
 

Udi

RM Chief Ornithologist
Mar 14, 2005
4,915
1,200
Just curious here, you're going to specify out ultra hard alloy and then run ti bolts in it?
I've run the same Ti bolts in my current stem for 8 years now.
My buddy @toodles has done the same for ~4 years if I recall correctly and he's a fair bit heavier than me, both our stem/bolt combos have been on ~4 DH bikes each and probably been to as many countries worth of chairlift parks. We've never broken any Ti bolts, and I'm on my 4th handlebar with it, think he's on his 3rd. Both on 800 wide bars atm.

I feel like Ti bolts aren't a problem. In fact I don't think 2014 alloy is a problem either, but my current stem is 7075 and I'd just like to keep that if possible - I'm definitely not saying everything outside my criteria is bad or anything - but I'm in no rush and would prefer something equal or better than what I currently have.

I try to buy the best parts I can and keep them for a *really* long time (another 8-year stem would be nice) so it's nice to spend the time to make the right choice - I had a similar thread about pedals here on RM and I'm still using the ones I picked there.
 
Last edited:

Udi

RM Chief Ornithologist
Mar 14, 2005
4,915
1,200
OT: which ones? Found no final conclusion.
Spank Spike with Ti spindles, also have Oozy/Ti on my trailbike (it's the same pedal just with more machining on the body). They've been pretty good.
 

Gary

"S" is for "neo-luddite"
Aug 27, 2002
7,649
5,562
UK
Dude. you weigh fuck all don't you?
rider weight definitely has to be taken into consideration when recommending Ti.
No way I'd ever run a Ti pedal spindle. I bend chromo pedal spindles and (M800) Saint crank arms FFS! Ti (in my experience) shears far too easily.
 

4130biker

PM me about Tantrum Cycles!
May 24, 2007
3,884
450
You don't actually adjust compression damping or bother with lockout on a Hardtail. Do you? :/
I can't believe I didn't think of the cable trick! I had the cartridge apart, seeing what I could do, since the POS defaults to lockout. Took all of five minutes to use a scrap cable and is a big improvement! Thanks! :cheers:
 

Udi

RM Chief Ornithologist
Mar 14, 2005
4,915
1,200
Dude. you weigh fuck all don't you?
rider weight definitely has to be taken into consideration when recommending Ti.
No way I'd ever run a Ti pedal spindle. I bend chromo pedal spindles and (M800) Saint crank arms FFS! Ti (in my experience) shears far too easily.
165-170# in American numbers.

You do realise there's different qualities of Ti and different dimensions of Ti components - so if we're talking about things like Ti pedal spindles the design and support/loading plays a large part in its load capacity (i.e. Ti may be appropriate for some pedals and not for others). If you're buying $1 Ti bolts off ebay they're probably not going to be as strong as a certified bolt from a reputable source either.

For reference - I've bent far more chromo pedal spindles than Ti in total (if you think I don't wreck stuff you're sadly mistaken), and I think that's partially due to the fact that a lot of "chromo" spindles aren't as strong as they could/should be. You definitely can't generalise based on material without specifying alloy at least.

Some facts though:
  1. Most pedals don't use the strongest grades of steel available for spindles
  2. Cheap Ti spindles and bolts from no-name brands can suck (no surprises here)
  3. Most steel bolts in MTB parts are far from the strongest grade of steel (tensile strength in brackets), with stems often using 8.8 (830MPa) or 10.9 (1040MPa) grade bolts instead of the strongest 12.9 (1220MPa). A few stems I looked into with this thread used stainless bolts (~800MPa). Titanium can range from 950-1100MPa so in a lot of cases a quality Titanium upgrade will leave you with a stronger or equal strength bolt.
  4. Even if you weighed 200#, the ~8% leverage increase of my wider bars would put more loading on my stem bolts than yours.
  5. Literally not a single rider on the WC DH circuit I have seen is using cranks that are as heavy as the original M800, many who would be much larger and faster than both of us (and I do love and use Saint cranks) - so maybe at this point we need to differentiate between products being strong enough and you having a one-off failure / being a hack. :D
Finally - I didn't recommend anything to anyone, but what I do recommend to anyone considering this stuff is to run the numbers. Just because Ti is weaker than the strongest steel, doesn't mean it's necessarily weaker than the steel part you're looking at replacing.
 
Last edited:

Gary

"S" is for "neo-luddite"
Aug 27, 2002
7,649
5,562
UK
1 no shit
2 no shit
3 no shit
4 Wrong. On so many counts.
5 no shit*

*not a one-off.

Try reading what I wrote instead of having a bullet pointed hissy fit
 

Udi

RM Chief Ornithologist
Mar 14, 2005
4,915
1,200
Hahaha, come on Gary, this is a thread about helping me pick a stem.
I'm not telling anyone to run anything, in fact I was asking people to tell me.

It's where I get to learn about a bunch of cool products and potentially put some shiny bling on my bike.

@Mo(n)arch - meant to ask earlier, what don't you like about the slide-on design, is it just the inconvenience or do you think there is a functional fault?
 

Mo(n)arch

Turbo Monkey
Dec 27, 2010
4,441
1,422
Italy/south Tyrol
@Mo(n)arch - meant to ask earlier, what don't you like about the slide-on design, is it just the inconvenience or do you think there is a functional fault?
Actually it's more of a personal preference really. At some point I had two bars that differed solely in height on two different bikes and swapped them out to see how bar height affected my riding. It was awesome to just open the screws of the brakes and the stem and having the bar plus grips already in your hands.

On the other side I'd fear to scratch my bars during the assembly or disassembly of the bar-stem combo, but that's maybe a no problem.

Another idea/question: Having dealt with tolerance problems in my old job in several occasions, how would a worst case scenario of 0,1 - 0,2mm of tolerances (paint, maybe an off product) affect the clamping and the forces in the stem with such a minimum of material around the bar? And that regarding in both scenarios: Overlap or play.
I reckon with painted parts milled in high production numbers the tolerances above aren't that far off, are they?
 
Last edited:

Udi

RM Chief Ornithologist
Mar 14, 2005
4,915
1,200
Actually it's more of a personal preference really.

Another idea/question: Having dealt with tolerance problems in my old job in several occasions, how would a worst case scenario of 0,1 - 0,2mm of tolerances (paint, maybe an off product) affect the clamping and the forces in the stem with such a minimum of material around the bar?
Fair call. I'm not too fussed as I rarely swap things out, and I think the single bolt clamp gives better load distribution. Valid point on the scratching thing though, potentially a concern during removal after it's been clamped for a while.

I think every good stem (and bar if alloy) should be anodized - paint/powdercoat gives inferior tolerances like you said, is an inferior finish in terms of long-term aesthetics, and adds weight for no reason. To answer your question though - most painted parts with clamping surfaces are re-machined after painting though - eg frames, boxxer crowns, painted stems, inside of painted brake lever clamps etc. This way tolerances are kept intact - however it also leaves raw aluminium which has a lower surface hardness than anodized aluminium and is generally just a poor quality finish - if you want to be pedantic.
 

Kanye West

220# bag of hacktastic
Aug 31, 2006
3,741
473
Actually it's more of a personal preference really. At some point I had two bars that differed solely in height on two different bikes and swapped them out to see how bar height affected my riding. It was awesome to just open the screws of the brakes and the stem and having the bar plus grips already in your hands.

On the other side I'd fear to scratch my bars during the assembly or disassembly of the bar-stem combo, but that's maybe a no problem.

Another idea/question: Having dealt with tolerance problems in my old job in several occasions, how would a worst case scenario of 0,1 - 0,2mm of tolerances (paint, maybe an off product) affect the clamping and the forces in the stem with such a minimum of material around the bar? And that regarding in both scenarios: Overlap or play.
I reckon with painted parts milled in high production numbers the tolerances above aren't that far off, are they?
Plan for maximum material condition (MMC) on each part. Also, allow some amount of flex in the front plate or in the ring that surrounds the bar. The bar itself will also have a small degree of ovalizing to it when clamped. The machining/bar forming isn't 100% perfect, and your clamping won't be either (gap won't be 100% equal on both sides of the clamp).
 

kickstand

Turbo Monkey
Sep 18, 2009
3,441
392
Fenton, MI
Random update, wife bent two pairs of bars this weekend. Easton havoc and a race face, starting to wonder if the wider clamping location doesn't allow the bar to flex At all and just forces it to bend?

Both times her crowns were slightly twisted too, so not light impacts by any means but I've also crashed hard enough to to twist the crowns but never Brent bars.....just a thought?
 

Udi

RM Chief Ornithologist
Mar 14, 2005
4,915
1,200
Both times her crowns were slightly twisted too, so not light impacts by any means but I've also crashed hard enough to to twist the crowns but never Brent bars.....just a thought?
Sounds pretty crazy, clearly your wife is the real MVP.
It looks like the Havoc is about the widest you can get so maybe a contributor, but it's not that much wider than the others really so maybe just unlucky crashes.

I decided the ANVL was still the best of the bunch for me and emailed them a few questions before ordering, but no reply after 7 days. Re-sent this morning, will see how it goes.