Quantcast

Cyclo vs. Road

crowjo

Chimp
Jul 29, 2010
2
0
Ashland, OR
So I'm definitely a newbie when it comes to the world of biking. I road bikes all the time as a kid (walmart or equivalent) I'm thinking of getting a cyclocross bike because there is a bike path around my area but it has a lot of bumps and I like the idea of being able to go off road. However, I was wondering 2 things. 1. Is it possible to buy road bike tires to put on a cyclo bike and basically turn it into a road bike. 2. Are the cyclo tires and bike itself suitable for long rides (50+ miles) The bike will mostly be used for 4 to 8 mile commuting. Thanks for any input you can provide.
 

sanjuro

Tube Smuggler
Sep 13, 2004
17,373
0
SF
1. Yes, cyclocross bikes will make fine road bikes.
2. Cyclocross tires will make lousy long distance tires.

Keep in mind the cyclocross bikes have no suspension and make so/so off-road bikes. Put it this way: the trails you are going to ride: would you ride them on your road bike? If so, then cyclocross bikes will do a great job.
 

JRogers

talks too much
Mar 19, 2002
3,785
1
Claremont, CA
First, you can put road tires on a CX bike. The wheels are the same size, but for normal size road tires and normal size CX tires you would need different tubes. Second, you can certainly do long rides on a CX bike. A road bike would be better for that for the most part, but it's not bad. Cross tires would not be that great for a really long ride, IMO.

I'd consider whether you really want a cross bike, though. What do you mean by the path being bumpy? Like bad pavement, rocks, hills? A CX bike won't be as good on the road due to geometry, likely build and other stuff. And they aren't terribly capable off-road. I have ridden some pretty hairy trails on a cross bike and it is usually slow and if there's any technical parts it is way harder/scarier than on a mountain bike. Obviously, you really can't go on trails on a road bike, but most dirt roads should be okay. A road bike with wider tires than normal can be fairly versatile.
 

crowjo

Chimp
Jul 29, 2010
2
0
Ashland, OR
well.. the paths I'm talking about is like a 60 mile paved bike path in my area. It connects pretty much everywhere i would need to go. Yes, the pavement is cracked and and not so smooth due to whatever reason. I'm not really thinking about taking it off road too often either I guess. Basically I had bought a road bike off craigslist last summer (stolen since) but both tires were popped within a few days of riding the trail.
 

ire

Turbo Monkey
Aug 6, 2007
6,196
4
A CX bike won't be as good on the road due to geometry, likely build and other stuff. And they aren't terribly capable off-road.
:thumbsdown:

Cross bikes do fine on the road and they're more durable. A cross bike will be heavier though. As for off road...get some skills son! :D
 

JRogers

talks too much
Mar 19, 2002
3,785
1
Claremont, CA
:thumbsdown:

Cross bikes do fine on the road and they're more durable. A cross bike will be heavier though. As for off road...get some skills son! :D
Yes, cross bikes do fine on the road. I was actually riding a cross bike on the road and some trails for the last 6 years or so until the start of this year. Rode it everywhere and liked it. Had a dedicated road bike before and have one again now. I just prefer the road frame slightly on the road due to the slightly sharper steering, lower bottom bracket, lower weight and lack of brake chatter. I preferred the cross bike when I lived in Vermont and rode on lots of icy dirt roads, non-technical trails. For bike paths, roads and the occasional dirt road the road bike is better with no real drawbacks....but I agree the difference is not that big for recreational riders (like myself).