Quantcast

Specialized Hillbilly Reviews?

vikingboy

Monkey
Dec 15, 2009
212
2
I ran the Stans Flow wheels with some Butcher SX tires (tubeless) at Sea Otter. (I have been running tubeless downhill for years with Maxxis UST on Mavic UST). I thought it would be a nice, light setup for the mellow DH course. On one of the practice runs I had quite a moment when this setup failed me. Landing a jump into some ruts, the front tire blew straight off the rim. I heard a pop, looked down, the tire was instantly flopping around my handlebars. The rim dug into the ground, and I went OTB, giving my Alpinestars neck brace quite the test. I went over to the Specialized tent for some insight on this failure. They said the tires aren't certified UST - that's a risk I take running the tires tubeless. I also talked to Mavic who ,of course had a slightly biased response, saying the Stans aren't certified tubeless. I believe Mavic helped create the certification. Anyway, in the interest of safety/reliability I thought I would share this info.

Exactly my results with flow rims too. Since moving to a proper ust rim (crossmax sx, Easton haven carbons and a pair of Easton havocs) I've ridden a mixture of maxxis and specialized tyres tubeless and never had any issues.

My call is for hard riding the bead seats on the ztr rims just isn't up to the job.
 

mtg

Green with Envy
Sep 21, 2009
1,862
1,604
Denver, CO
Vikingboy and brocelif: that's exactly why I only use UST rims with tires designed to be run tubeless. Apparently a lot of people on the internet think I'm a moron for sticking to my guns about only using tubeless systems that are designed for that use, but I don't want to be burping tires or blowing them off rims.
Thanks for posting your experiences. And, Landcruiser: that's why I requested Spesh extend the 2Bliss technology to the gravity tires. I also made a similar request to Maxxis, that they make all of their gravity tires tubeless ready so we can have more/better options for carcass and rubber compound and still have robust tubeless mounting. Tall order, yes, but it would be awesome.

For reference, my trail bike has Crossmax SX wheels, and my DH bike has Deemax. Trail tires are currently tubeless ready Schwalbes and DH tires are UST High Rollers.
 
Last edited:

marshalolson

Turbo Monkey
May 25, 2006
1,770
519
i think the point is that the notubes rims are at least as good and generally better than any other converted rim setup. i personally could not keep single ply tires on the flows i had, but had no issue with 2 ply tires.

the non-ust maxxis dh casing tires work awesome tubeless on an 823 that much can be considered fact, but careful with stan's as the ammonium in it eats the maxxis rubber. you are better off with a latex home-brew. maxxis even used to claim that use of stan's sealant on ANY of their tires voided the warranty. not sure if that is still the stance.
 

mtg

Green with Envy
Sep 21, 2009
1,862
1,604
Denver, CO
i think the point is that the notubes rims are at least as good and generally better than any other converted rim setup. i personally could not keep single ply tires on the flows i had, but had no issue with 2 ply tires.

the non-ust maxxis dh casing tires work awesome tubeless on an 823 that much can be considered fact, but careful with stan's as the ammonium in it eats the maxxis rubber. you are better off with a latex home-brew. maxxis even used to claim that use of stan's sealant on ANY of their tires voided the warranty. not sure if that is still the stance.
I think Maxxis no longer has issues with Stan's, as I've been running that sealant in my Maxxis UST tires for a couple years.
 

sbabuser

Turbo Monkey
Dec 22, 2004
1,114
55
Golden, CO
I've had no issues w/ DT, Sun, WTB or Azonic rims and ghetto tubeless on Maxxis dh tires since '05. WTB trail bike tires have worked well, too. Well, so long as I remember to add some sealant before they completely dry up, anyway.
 

landcruiser

Monkey
May 9, 2002
186
40
San Jose, CA
Will those ground control replace the Eskar's? I like my Eskar's, but would like something with a little more support for "intermediate" leaning...
Nope. Not a replacement for any current tire. Just a supplement to our line as a do-it-all, light, fast XC trail tire.

And, Landcruiser: that's why I requested Spesh extend the 2Bliss technology to the gravity tires. ...so we can have more/better options for carcass and rubber compound and still have robust tubeless mounting. Tall order, yes, but it would be awesome.
Definitely no promises there, but it's been noted.
 

mtg

Green with Envy
Sep 21, 2009
1,862
1,604
Denver, CO
In this day and age, if you're getting robust...use a tube.:thumb:
I disagree.
In my experience, when people have issues with tubeless, it's because they're doing it wrong, and then end up blaming the tubeless setup instead of themselves for getting details wrong. For example, if you mount tires that aren't designed to be run tubeless on a standard rim that you sealed with tape, and then it doesn't work....well, it wasn't designed to work tubeless.
On the other hand, if you use UST rims with either UST tires or TLR tires and sealant, it's just about stupid-proof and with sealant it eliminates two failure modes that exist with tubes: pinch flats and small punctures.

I'm not saying properly done tubeless systems are infallible by any means, but done correctly, mounting a tire and holding pressure is equivalently robust to a tube, but you ditch two failure modes.

It's all in the details.....:thumb:
 
Last edited:

slyfink

Turbo Monkey
Sep 16, 2008
9,323
5,074
Ottawa, Canada
I disagree.
In my experience, when people have issues with tubeless, it's because they're doing it wrong, and then end up blaming the tubeless setup instead of themselves for getting details wrong. For example, if you mount tires that aren't designed to be run tubeless on a standard rim that you sealed with tape, and then it doesn't work....well, it wasn't designed to work tubeless.
On the other hand, if you use UST rims with either UST tires or TLR tires and sealant, it's just about stupid-proof and with sealant it eliminates two failure modes that exist with tubes: pinch flats and small punctures.

I'm not saying properly done tubeless systems are infallible by any means, but done correctly, mounting a tire and holding pressure is equivalently robust to a tube, but you ditch two failure modes.

It's all in the details.....:thumb:
and I'll disagree with you too. this issue has been discussed on RM at length. The issue with tubeless for DH is blowing the bead off the rim under high cornering loads. even the best, most robust system (true UST) has a hard time holding the tires on under really hard cornering. I think the last time it was discussed was during Canberra Worlds when Sick Mick tried tubeless and had some sort of dual valve thing going on. Everyone talked about the solution Vouilloz had come up with that was some sort of small tube inside the tire that pressed the bead against the beadlock of the rim.

It used to be that such hard cornering was only the domain of pros, but it seems that with improved bike technology, tire technology, more instructional materials available and an increased interest in racing, that more and more people (average joes) can achieve that level of cornering.

However.... these days it seems that more and more DH pros are giving tubeless a try. Off the top of my head there's Gee and Bryn for the men and at least Sabrina for the ladies. So maybe there's some RD going on now to improve the bead lock.

But given current technologies, for a really aggressive rider, I don't think tubeless for DH is quite ready yet.

Actually, after having written all that, I'd actually say that tubeless for DH is probably OK for 80% (totally off the top of my head estimate) of riders. It's only in cases where a rider likes to corner hard that it may not work so well. So in the end I don't entirely disagree with you, maybe only a little!
 

kidwoo

Artisanal Tweet Curator
I disagree.
In my experience, when people have issues with tubeless, it's because they're doing it wrong, and then end up blaming the tubeless setup instead of themselves for getting details wrong. For example, if you mount tires that aren't designed to be run tubeless on a standard rim that you sealed with tape, and then it doesn't work....well, it wasn't designed to work tubeless.
On the other hand, if you use UST rims with either UST tires or TLR tires and sealant, it's just about stupid-proof and with sealant it eliminates two failure modes that exist with tubes: pinch flats and small punctures.

I'm not saying properly done tubeless systems are infallible by any means, but done correctly, mounting a tire and holding pressure is equivalently robust to a tube, but you ditch two failure modes.

It's all in the details.....:thumb:
And you gain an entirely new failure mode even when done 'correctly'
 

'size

Turbo Monkey
May 30, 2007
2,000
338
AZ

'size

Turbo Monkey
May 30, 2007
2,000
338
AZ
Oh hell yeah. Hopefully that's at least a hard compound center tread.
they currently offer 70/60; 65/55, and 50/45 for the dual compound tires - i'm hoping for 50/45 like the clutch but can deal with 65/55...
 

landcruiser

Monkey
May 9, 2002
186
40
San Jose, CA
Been waiting for someone to catch on...

Butcher Control 2.3

(pic on bike)

  • Single ply, 2bliss 60tpi casing.
  • Single compound 50a durometer.
  • Tread is slightly lower profile than the DH version.
  • 730g

Kidwoo, I know you were asking for 60a for longer wear. We're going with 50a for now for the guys who really want that grip. You'll see the Stumpy Evo's and the Enduro's all come with a Butcher 2.3 up front, Purgatory 2.2 rear for pedaling/wear.
 
Last edited:

'size

Turbo Monkey
May 30, 2007
2,000
338
AZ
Been waiting for someone to catch on...

Butcher Control 2.3

(pic on bike)

  • Single ply 60tpi casing.
  • Single compound 50a durometer.
  • Tread is slightly lower profile than the DH version.

Kidwoo, I know you were asking for 60a for longer wear. We're going with 50a for now for the guys who really want that grip. You'll see the Stumpy Evo's and the Enduro's all come with a Butcher 2.3 up front, Purgatory 2.2 rear for pedaling/wear.
thanks landcruiser!
any idea of weight and aftermarket availability?
 

landcruiser

Monkey
May 9, 2002
186
40
San Jose, CA
Updated the previous post, but weights are coming in around 730g give or take.

Last I heard, they'll be out to the shops around Sept 1, but don't quote me on that.
 

kidwoo

Artisanal Tweet Curator
Been waiting for someone to catch on...

Kidwoo, I know you were asking for 60a for longer wear.
Not really anything to do with wear at all. More like speed/accleration and pedaling efficiency.

I know you know the feeling of climbing with a soft center tread tire on the rear.

Either way, I'm stoked to see the trickle down.

Thanks for the info man!
 

vikingboy

Monkey
Dec 15, 2009
212
2
good news - now lets hope these are available via Specialized Uk this year.
Sadly they didnt bring the butcher sx & dh into the Uk last year.
 

landcruiser

Monkey
May 9, 2002
186
40
San Jose, CA
Not really anything to do with wear at all. More like speed/accleration and pedaling efficiency.

I know you know the feeling of climbing with a soft center tread tire on the rear.

Either way, I'm stoked to see the trickle down.

Thanks for the info man!
Ah, well they should be a little better in that regard due to the lower tread height (not a full, squirmy dh block), but I understand your concern.

good news - now lets hope these are available via Specialized Uk this year.
Sadly they didnt bring the butcher sx & dh into the Uk last year.
Get all your friends and call your reps! The people that choose what to stock don't listen to us, they listen to the customers.
 

slyfink

Turbo Monkey
Sep 16, 2008
9,323
5,074
Ottawa, Canada
Been waiting for someone to catch on...

Butcher Control 2.3

(pic on bike)

  • Single ply, 2bliss 60tpi casing.
  • Single compound 50a durometer.
  • Tread is slightly lower profile than the DH version.
  • 730g

Kidwoo, I know you were asking for 60a for longer wear. We're going with 50a for now for the guys who really want that grip. You'll see the Stumpy Evo's and the Enduro's all come with a Butcher 2.3 up front, Purgatory 2.2 rear for pedaling/wear.
Not really anything to do with wear at all. More like speed/accleration and pedaling efficiency.

I know you know the feeling of climbing with a soft center tread tire on the rear.

Either way, I'm stoked to see the trickle down.

Thanks for the info man!
I'm not w the Kid on this one. I've been looking for a 2.3, soft, +/- 700g, tubeless compatible tire. It's remarkably hard to come by.

Will it come in 2Bliss Armadillo or GRID versions? If so, I can't wait to get my paws on some.

Either way, thanks for the info...
 

landcruiser

Monkey
May 9, 2002
186
40
San Jose, CA
No Armadillo or GRID versions at this time. Just the Control 2bliss.

What's more important to you? The extra puncture protection or 700g weight? Going to Armadillo or Grid construction would noticeably increase the weight.

If you just want the tougher construction, have you tried setting up the SX version tubeless? Just cause we don't endorse it, doesn't mean it might not work...
 

kidwoo

Artisanal Tweet Curator
No Armadillo or GRID versions at this time. Just the Control 2bliss.

What's more important to you? The extra puncture protection or 700g weight? Going to Armadillo or Grid construction would noticeably increase the weight.

If you just want the tougher construction, have you tried setting up the SX version tubeless? Just cause we don't endorse it, doesn't mean it might not work...
I've got an old sx casing (before they were called sx) chunder on the front of my trail bike right now, came stock on a demo 7 I bought years ago. I've been running it tubeless on some mavic 819s just fine for what it's worth.

I'd be down with a thicker casing on some of these smaller butchers as well. That 700g weight says to me that I probably couldn't get it to last very long tubeless based on my history with tires in that weight range in the past.

I'm running a 2.35 dh casing minion tubeless on the back right now for reference.

The big reasons I haven't bought some of the sx casing butchers is the compound and the size. When I kill this chunder, I may get one for the front only though.

Can't please everybody I know ;)
 

slyfink

Turbo Monkey
Sep 16, 2008
9,323
5,074
Ottawa, Canada
No Armadillo or GRID versions at this time. Just the Control 2bliss.

What's more important to you? The extra puncture protection or 700g weight? Going to Armadillo or Grid construction would noticeably increase the weight.

If you just want the tougher construction, have you tried setting up the SX version tubeless? Just cause we don't endorse it, doesn't mean it might not work...
Yeah I know... I'd love the light weight, but my reality is that I tend to cut the sidewalls of my tires before they get a chance to wear out. so even at 800 to 850g, I'll take the sidewall protection...

i'm running Stan's Arch rims right now, and I'm not convinced a regular beaded tire will run as well on them as a proper UST tire. I suppose I could see if my local shop has some SX casing tires on sale and give it a shot...

thanks for all the input...
 

'size

Turbo Monkey
May 30, 2007
2,000
338
AZ
MSRP on a 3C High Roller 2 is $93.
two different tires designed for two different types of riding from two different manufacturers; 3C vs. single compound, etc.

all the other standard 'control' tires top out at $55 so seeing this at $20 more was a bit of a surprise.

also for 2012 the ground control tire is back. not that it really fits in with the tires discussed here but it was a popular tire for xc/trail riding ages ago and is being offered in a 2.3 now.
 

Dogboy

Turbo Monkey
Apr 12, 2004
3,209
584
Durham, NC
two different tires designed for two different types of riding from two different manufacturers; 3C vs. single compound, etc.
Two DH tires made in the same factory. All I was implying is that DH tires have gotten pretty expensive. That is all.
 

'size

Turbo Monkey
May 30, 2007
2,000
338
AZ
Two DH tires made in the same factory. All I was implying is that DH tires have gotten pretty expensive. That is all.
the butcher control is not a DH tire, it's a single ply 730g trail tire. but yes, tire costs in general are crazy. i was just surprised to see this tire priced so much higher than equivalent category and usage tires from S. i guess molds and design/first run costs need to be recouped.
 

davec113

Monkey
May 24, 2009
419
0
Wow, $75?

I just got a Eskar2 2.3 Control for $45, running tubed on the rear of my trailbike. Butcher is $30 more? It sounds like a great front tire option, but not at that price...
 

Salami

Turbo Monkey
Jul 17, 2003
1,784
118
Waxhaw, NC
the butcher control tires are now available on the S website and i imagine through your S dealer. $75 retail - ouch.
While I understand tire prices have gone up a lot over that last couple of years $75 for a single ply MTB is full ****ing retard. I thought this was going to be the holy grail trail bike tire. But ****, $75?

The ****ing super high performance Michelin tires on my car where only $45 more. For a car. Not a effin MTB..

****. ****.

Can't some one make a tire like this for ~$50?
 

JimEG

Chimp
May 29, 2006
70
0
Capitol Forest
While I understand tire prices have gone up a lot over that last couple of years $75 for a single ply MTB is full ****ing retard. I thought this was going to be the holy grail trail bike tire. But ****, $75?

The ****ing super high performance Michelin tires on my car where only $45 more. For a car. Not a effin MTB..

****. ****.

Can't some one make a tire like this for ~$50?
This pricing escalation is Schwalbe's fault

The 730 gram Butcher Control looks to be on the money for aggressive trail riding/super d on a dry day

Would really like to see Storm and a Hill Billy in a more trail rider/super d friendly weight/casing. The only option for a quality spike type tire that is not on a DH casing is the pathetically puny Maxxis Medusa. A Control Storm and a Control Hill Billy in a 2.3 please. With the explosion of Super D and Enduro races these tires have to happen. They would have been on every other bike at the Sandy Ridge Spring Super D Series if they had existed 6 months ago.

Keep up the good work Specialized.
 
Last edited: