[stoney]

First off, there is a reason these guys are not actors. Otherwise, whole lot of badass. It's a solid 'go America, fcuk yeah', but the fight scenes are awesome. Wifey enjoyed it too. It has new generation Top Gun potential.

 

[mattmatt86]

Critics Consensus: Act of Valor Misses the Mark

Meh, Sounds like I'll pass. RT reviews are pretty spot on, I normally don't see anything less than 60%. Especially given the current cost to see a movie.

 

[stevew]

it was meant to be a recruiting tool and really nothing more.

if the critics were expecting more....that's their own fault.

 

[dhmike]

Critics Consensus: Act of Valor Misses the Mark

Meh, Sounds like I'll pass. RT reviews are pretty spot on, I normally don't see anything less than 60%. Especially given the current cost to see a movie.

 

[jimmydean]

it was meant to be a recruiting tool and really nothing more.

if the critics were expecting more....that's their own fault.

Worked in 1990.

 

[Uncle Cliffy]

Worked in 1990.

 

[stoney]

At $6 per ticket at matinee, it was fine. Not a good acting move, just a cool movie. It was like a video game in real.

 

[gonefirefightin]

just looking at the previews was enough to make me wait for it on DVD.

 

[stevew]

from stars/stripes

WASHINGTON (AP) -- Navy SEALs never expected the film "Act of Valor," starring real, active-duty Navy SEALs, to be this big.

Five years ago, commanders allowed a small, independent film company into their elite ranks to turn real-life training exercises into a feature-length movie in hopes of drumming up recruits fast.

SEAL officers thought the film would open in a couple of theaters in military towns, then quietly move to cable television, where re-runs would draw likeminded youths to join the special operations world.

Then came the Navy SEALs raid that killed Osama bin Laden in Pakistan last year, and a high-profile hostage rescue in Somalia last month. President Barack Obama delivered his State of the Union address and gave a shout out to SEALs, with Adm. Bill McRaven, the SEAL and bin Laden raid commander, sitting quietly in Obama's box.

Now, the once modest recruiting project is set to open Feb. 24 in roughly 2,500 theaters nationwide, putting an uncomfortable spotlight on a group that prides itself on keeping its collective mouth shut about clandestine operations.

The officers and staff who helped bring the film about spoke on condition of anonymity because they are embarrassed by the massive media blitz and public interest, and - most of all - they are tired of getting grief from their special operations colleagues, whose daring exploits haven't made it into the headlines.

One of the few that's gone on record is overall special operations commander McRaven.

"It was initially started as a recruiting film so we could help recruit minorities into the teams," McRaven explained. He said he didn't think the film gave anything away to the enemy, nor would it put in danger the SEALs who starred in it.

McRaven told a Washington audience recently that he'd signed up for special operations forces after seeing the 1968 John Wayne film, "The Green Berets," and that he had worked on the movie "Raise the Titanic" as a young ensign, also to drive recruitment.

Toward that end, the script was designed to showcase two things, according to producer-directors Mike "Mouse" McCoy and Scott Waugh: real acts of valor by SEALs on the battlefield since Sept. 11, and the SEALs' unique technical abilities to reach a target by sea, air or land as the acronym suggests.

"We say to the team, `How would you do the operation?'" like capturing a terror suspect on a yacht, "and we would augment our camera plan to film what they came up with," McCoy said in an interview.

"That's why the movie took four years to make because we would have to wait for that training" to film a particular skill, Waugh added.

At a special preview in Washington last fall, the reaction from the SEAL community was positive overall. The preview was one of many the producers, known as the Bandito Brothers, made possible, both to gauge the community's reaction and to raise money for the Naval SEAL Foundation, which benefits families of fallen SEALs.

The SEALs take pride in how much the movie gets right, such as how the team meets up with a submarine mid-ocean or jumps from aircraft thousands of feet above ground to land accurately to rescue a hostage in a remote location, just as they did in Somalia. None of the special operators thought it gave too much away to the enemy in terms of tactics.

Some SEALS, however, griped that the film was not technically perfect. For instance, during the high-altitude, low-opening parachute scenes, the SEALs have casual chats with the plane door open before strapping on oxygen masks and jumping out. One operator said they would have had the masks on for half an hour beforehand. Also, the Bandito Brothers requested the explosions be slightly larger than they would be in the field, and the guns often were un-silenced.

After the pre-screening, there was a deep sigh among SEALs about their comrades' acting ability. With one notable exception of a SEAL who pulls off a completely improvised interrogation scene, the SEALs thought their colleagues' acting was pretty clumsy. But they admit they've heard each other talk like that - awkward, heartfelt goodbyes to loved ones they won't see for months or stilted speeches before an operation. But they hope the audience will be forgiving.

The Bandito Brothers say the critics they most feared were the guys with whom they made the film.

"We had one goal: that the guys would want to share a beer with us afterwards," said McCoy. "And we still are."

 

[DirtMcGirk]

Those navy guys always struck me as a weepy bunch...

 

[mandown]

better pay for a ticket or a copy. if GFF finds you sneaked in or stole it, he will punch you in the parking lot.

 

[DirtMcGirk]

GFF was Army too. I don't think he'd mind. Now forget to pay up on some Wounded Warrior stuff, he might cripple you. I support that.

 

[IH8Rice]

At $6 per ticket at matinee, it was fine. Not a good acting move, just a cool movie. It was like a video game in real.

i concur.

 

[kazlx]

I liked it. Was well worth the matinee price. I thought it was better than half the crap hollywood puts out, even with Navy Seals trying to act.

 

[amishmatt]

Worked in 1990.

 

[dante]

just looking at the previews was enough to make me wait to get it free from the library.

ftfy.

 

[bean]

It sounds like they had rather unprecedented access to the SEALs. It's too bad they didn't make a great documentary instead of a crappy movie.

 

[Sandwich]

I liked it. Was well worth the matinee price. I thought it was better than half the crap hollywood puts out, even with Navy Seals trying to act.

rather them then another samuel blackson or john travolta film

 

[OGRipper]

It sounds like they had rather unprecedented access to the SEALs. It's too bad they didn't make a great documentary instead of a crappy movie.

It should be easy to get access when you are basically hired by your subject to make a thinly-veiled recruiting/marketing tool, especially since they probably had approval rights for the finished product.

I suspect access would be a lot different for an independent documentary. Like, what kind of access would Michael Moore get?

 

[-BB-]

better pay for a ticket or a copy. if GFF finds you sneaked in or stole it, he will punch you in the parking lot.

Is that code for in his nuts?

 

[MikeD]

Why try to make them act (per se) or give them a script? Just work with them to set scenarios, let them work through it, film it like a documentary.

Ed: missed Bean's post.