How can he get away with saying that when Rush got toasted for saying something less offensive about McNabb? At least Rush's comment could've been taken in different ways. Boykin, heh, Boykin... say it with me, I knew you could... is clearly spewing hate (based on that one quote)."Well you know what I knew, that my God was bigger than his," said Lt Gen Boykin. "I knew that my God was a real God, and his was an idol."
Is dude trying to cast a speel on his audience?Originally posted by $tinkle
rummy leads the press corps in "Onward Christian Solders (Marching on to War)"
Nice logic Shirley....so if I'm talking to the Aryan Brotherhood calling black people "n*****s" is OK. More clueless than usual and usual is very clueless.Originally posted by BurlySurly
Ok, did you guys read the article or not?
he was speaking to CHURCH CONGREGATIONS.
I think that's perfectly acceptable in that context. Once again, the media headlines dont match the actual story. Next.
The dude's a christian talking to other christians. What right do you or i have to say about what he preaches? If his faith lends credit to his military abilities, than so be it. If its detrimental, than it should be dealt with. Muslim and Christian religions are equally unaccepting of one another, what's the news here? This article took a guy's sermon out of context and tiwisted it to fit a controversial news article. Happens all the time. I think you dont have any idea what you're talking about, yet again, becuase you're so anti-everything that makes a bit of sense that you wouldnt see something for what it is if it bit you on the ass.Originally posted by valve bouncer
Nice logic Shirley....so if I'm talking to the Aryan Brotherhood calling black people "n*****s" is OK. More clueless than usual and usual is very clueless.
I see you are far too dense to see the point, ho-hum, what else is new. Did you read the part where he's addressing the congregation in his uniform? This guy is not only being incredibly intolerant he is also ignorant of basic facts, no wonder you like him. An intolerant bigot without a clue, gives you a stiffy I'm sure Shirly.Originally posted by BurlySurly
The dude's a christian talking to other christians. What right do you or i have to say about what he preaches? If his faith lends credit to his military abilities, than so be it. If its detrimental, than it should be dealt with. Muslim and Christian religions are equally unaccepting of one another, what's the news here? This article took a guy's sermon out of context and tiwisted it to fit a controversial news article. Happens all the time. I think you dont have any idea what you're talking about, yet again, becuase you're so anti-everything that makes a bit of sense that you wouldnt see something for what it is if it bit you on the ass.
Let's just have a smilie contest. :devil: :devil: : : :devil: :angry: :angry:Originally posted by valve bouncer
I see you are far too dense to see the point, ho-hum, what else is new. Did you read the part where he's addressing the congregation in his uniform? This guy is not only being incredibly intolerant he is also ignorant of basic facts, no wonder you like him. An intolerant bigot without a clue, gives you a stiffy I'm sure Shirly.
I accept your concessionOriginally posted by BurlySurly
Let's just have a smilie contest. :devil: :devil: : : :devil: :angry: :angry:
so you're saying that going to heaven and getting 69 virgins is a bad thingOriginally posted by nydave
Their God tells them if they die killing Americans they go to their heaven and get 69 virgins. And you people rip on an American for calling that a work of Satan???
Originally posted by nydave
because we are a christian nation, also because they despise the fact that we support Israel too. I guess that makes USA evil?
This was in Iraq i believe, No other clothes may be worn by servicemembers than uniforms, even at these mock churches.Originally posted by Silver
So Boykin's god is bigger than Osama's god. Great, doesn't that dumbass Boykin see that is what got us into the situation in the first place?
Also, he shouldn't be wearing the uniform if he's speaking in a church.
You want to bet his ass would be canned in about 2 seconds if he wore his uniform and spoke at a gay pride parade?
Dave is "technically" wrong, though not actually. Either way, the VAST majority of the US military is christian....and that's to whom he was speaking... a christian congeregation.Originally posted by Silver
Show me in the constitution where it says the United States is a Christian nation.
of courseOriginally posted by nydave
Are you saying killing Americans is okay?
Originally posted by Silver
BurlySurly, Boykin isn't a chaplain, and he wasn't speaking in Iraq.
Like I said, if he's going to speak like this in churches, the uniform needs to come off.
MSNBC Link
lets not start this one in here.Originally posted by nydave
but don't try and tell me that it isn't abnormal behavior. The US military has a policy..it's called "don't ask, don't tell". Preaching at a gay rights rally would be "telling". I got to stay off this "political forum" because some of you are making me sick.
So you'd be cool if a Muslim Lt. General (that is another thing that is important here: This isn't an NCO or a low level officer) of the US military told a group of people in a mosque that Allah was truly greater than the Jewish God, and that Allah would overcome all?Originally posted by BurlySurly
Still, the uniform he was wearing is authorized for that use. He can say what he wants in church regardless of whether you think its ok or not. He doesnt have to be chaplain to express his opinion on god. I was merely mentioning chaplains to show that the US endorses religion in certain respects.
yes.Originally posted by Silver
So you'd be cool if a Muslim Lt. General (that is another thing that is important here: This isn't an NCO or a low level officer) of the US military told a group of people in a mosque that Allah was truly greater than the Jewish God, and that Allah would overcome all?
Can we agree killing any nationality is equally bad?Originally posted by nydave
Are you saying killing Americans is okay?
Are you saying killing Arabs is okay?Originally posted by nydave
Are you saying killing Americans is okay?
Sorry Burly, but you know I'm on this one like flies on horsesh!t...Originally posted by nydave
but don't try and tell me that it isn't abnormal behavior. The US military has a policy..it's called "don't ask, don't tell". Preaching at a gay rights rally would be "telling". I got to stay off this "political forum" because some of you are making me sick.
so tell me moony (not bright enough to be called sunny), does separation of church and state only work to the favor of the liberal snots in the country? because it seems to me that this man was giving a sermon, thus, aimed at "the church" and therefore he is able to speak whatever religious phrases he wishes. the fact that he's wearing his uniform has absolutely nothing to do with his right to speak such things. and what basic facts is he so ignorant of? he's there...you're not, i'm sure your media connections are far more credible when it comes to warOriginally posted by valve bouncer
I see you are far too dense to see the point, ho-hum, what else is new. Did you read the part where he's addressing the congregation in his uniform? This guy is not only being incredibly intolerant he is also ignorant of basic facts, no wonder you like him. An intolerant bigot without a clue, gives you a stiffy I'm sure Shirly.
Freedom of religion is a subset of freedom of speech. Now, since BS works in the propaganda arm D ) of the Marines if I'm not mistaken, I'm sure that he will confirm that as long as you're wearing that uniform, you don't have freedom of speech.Originally posted by manimal
so tell me moony (not bright enough to be called sunny), does separation of church and state only work to the favor of the liberal snots in the country? because it seems to me that this man was giving a sermon, thus, aimed at "the church" and therefore he is able to speak whatever religious phrases he wishes. the fact that he's wearing his uniform has absolutely nothing to do with his right to speak such things. and what basic facts is he so ignorant of? he's there...you're not, i'm sure your media connections are far more credible when it comes to war
wasn't there an argument just recently about a member of the military attending a peace rally during wartime? And shee-it, he wasn't even wearing his uniform, but he still got in trouble.Originally posted by manimal
the fact that he's wearing his uniform has absolutely nothing to do with his right to speak such things.
Now I realise you've just had a lobotomy to enter the force (un-necessary in your case) but this is a new low for even one such as you who I thought couldn't go any lower. The guy is a bigot pure and simple, moreover he's a bigot with power over the very people he despises. He calls Allah an "idol", anyone with even a little bit of knowledge is aware that Muslims, Christians and Jews pray to the same god. I guess you don't even have a little bit of knowledge, but I knew that already, you've proved it countless times. Now I know that bigotry is something you and your ilk hold dear to your little black hearts, but really porky it is unacceptable and as much as you'd like to spurt out your vile little tracts of vitriol free of censure it ain't gonna happen. Now go oil ya truncheon orificer.Originally posted by manimal
so tell me moony (not bright enough to be called sunny), does separation of church and state only work to the favor of the liberal snots in the country? because it seems to me that this man was giving a sermon, thus, aimed at "the church" and therefore he is able to speak whatever religious phrases he wishes. the fact that he's wearing his uniform has absolutely nothing to do with his right to speak such things. and what basic facts is he so ignorant of? he's there...you're not, i'm sure your media connections are far more credible when it comes to war
I'm not going to touch the rest of the post, however, this statement is misleading. It really depends on who you talk to. Not condoning the General's speech on this one (or condemning it) but just saying that this is a blanket statement and really does not give the issue any of the complexity it deserves.Originally posted by valve bouncer
He calls Allah an "idol", anyone with even a little bit of knowledge is aware that Muslims, Christians and Jews pray to the same god.
coming from a wannbe cop... i ve heard it all nowOriginally posted by manimal
so tell me moony (not bright enough to be called sunny
Its funny you say that, because you know as well as i, that if this were a muslim general saying these things, You and the rest of these peace mongers would be all over protecting his freedom of speech.Originally posted by Silver
I've said in the past that I can't wait until we have a Scientologist elected to some important office...I can't wait to see how important that separation becomes for some people.
Not if he had a uniform on, I wouldn't. I'd be on his ass just as quickly.Originally posted by BurlySurly
Its funny you say that, because you know as well as i, that if this were a muslim general saying these things, You and the rest of these peace mongers would be all over protecting his freedom of speech.
Listen, the dude said it to a church. The uniform he is wearing is authorized for that purpose by the DoD. He's served as an honorable man, with no marks for crusading on his record. I see no reason for all the fuss.
what part of sworn officer is "wannabe" by the way?Originally posted by partsbara
coming from a wannbe cop... i ve heard it all now
i think i ll call you sean hannity from now on manimal... either that of a conservative who walks with his head up his a$$.... wait on a second... they are one and the same right ?>$%#&#$^
partsbara
Originally posted by manimal
what part of sworn officer is "wannabe" by the way?