Quantcast

All time best metal records?

DNA

The human raccoon
Jan 31, 2003
1,443
0
NH
Zark said:
Mastadon ehh. Someone else here was telling me I'd like them a lot. Time to do some music shopping:)
I am slightly hesitant to give a recent album (2004) such high praise, but I keep putting it in the CD player at home, it has stayed on my iPod and it was the first album that came to mind when this thread was re-animated.

That said, you'll probably buy it and hate it.
 

SilentJ

trail builder
Jun 17, 2002
1,312
0
Calgary AB
I was rocking to
Dope - Felons And Revolutionaries
this morning. It's pretty good. I need to pick up "Life"

I like (no order):
Metallica - Master of Puppets
Anthrax - Persistence of Time
Rob Zombie - Hellbilly Deluxe
Ozzy - No More Tears
Pantera - Gotta call a tie between FBD and Vulgar Display
 

CrabJoe StretchPants

Reincarnated Crab Walking Head Spinning Bruce Dick
Nov 30, 2003
14,163
2,484
Groton, MA
lamb of god - as the palaces burn
killswitch engage - alive or just breathing
as i lay dying - frail words collapse
unearth - the oncoming storm
shadows fall - the war within


and the BEST metal/hardcore artist/album in my opinion:
since the flood - valor and vengeance

EDIT - not really all time, but favorite at the moment...
 

H8R

Cranky Pants
Nov 10, 2004
13,959
35
DNA said:
This may be my favorite metal album. It is in the top 5 at the very least.
Bros!




I'm on the left...No, not in the orange shirt.
 

mxer338

Monkey
May 9, 2005
324
0
CT
Tool-Opiate
Tool-Undertow
Tool-Aenima
Tool-Lateralus
(in no particular order)

pantera and slayer can fight for number 5

i only like tool a little bit, i swear:love:
 

H8R

Cranky Pants
Nov 10, 2004
13,959
35
mxer338 said:
Tool-Opiate
Tool-Undertow
Tool-Aenima
Tool-Lateralus
(in no particular order)

pantera and slayer can fight for number 5

i only like tool a little bit, i swear:love:
Hmm.

I haven't met the Tool folks, but i imagine Slayer or Pantera would eat them alive for spots 1-4.

I put my money on Phil, he had a boxing trainer.
 

Fool

The Thing cannot be described
Sep 10, 2001
2,781
1,494
Brooklyn
H8R said:
I put my money on Phil, he had a boxing trainer.
Isn't he all heroined out now?

Behemoth is my breakthrough corpsepaint band this year, which probably has nothing to do with this topic.
 

mxer338

Monkey
May 9, 2005
324
0
CT
H8R said:
Hmm.

I haven't met the Tool folks, but i imagine Slayer or Pantera would eat them alive for spots 1-4.

I put my money on Phil, he had a boxing trainer.
i know deep down inside that your right, but the topic could have been favorite american idol winner and my answer would have been the same
 

SK6

Turbo Monkey
Jul 10, 2001
7,586
0
Shut up and ride...
Iron Maiden -Peace of Mind
Judas Priest - Unleashed in the East
Shadows Fall - The War Within
Tobias Sammet - Avantasia
Accept - Metal Heart
Queensryche - Operation Mindcrime


Now, you have to realize, this was a tough ass list to compile since there are so many. And yes, there are six.

Now I DARE YOU to argue THAT selection!

LOL, all the selections made by all are awesome!!!! :thumb:
 

narlus

Eastcoast Softcore
Staff member
Nov 7, 2001
24,658
63
behind the viewfinder
sirknight6 said:
Iron Maiden -Peace of Mind
Judas Priest - Unleashed in the East
Shadows Fall - The War Within
Tobias Sammet - Avantasia
Accept - Metal Heart
Queensryche - Operation Mindcrime


Now, you have to realize, this was a tough ass list to compile since there are so many. And yes, there are six.

Now I DARE YOU to argue THAT selection!

LOL, all the selections made by all are awesome!!!! :thumb:
i've honestly never heard any of those records, but Accept?

all i can think of is that creepy little german dude who beavis and butthead made fun of.
 

SK6

Turbo Monkey
Jul 10, 2001
7,586
0
Shut up and ride...
narlus said:
i've honestly never heard any of those records, but Accept?

all i can think of is that creepy little german dude who beavis and butthead made fun of.
yea, a great solid album thathad substance and a lot of feel to it...Metal heart was a great album...

But I want to figure out who this asshole is:

 

SK6

Turbo Monkey
Jul 10, 2001
7,586
0
Shut up and ride...
narlus said:
i've honestly never heard any of those records, but Accept?

all i can think of is that creepy little german dude who beavis and butthead made fun of.

Iron Maiden -Peace of Mind


Your kidding right?

Judas Priest - Unleashed in the East


Again, kidding right?

Shadows Fall - The War Within


I thought you'd know this one......

Tobias Sammet - Avantasia

definitely underground, but clean production...

Accept - Metal Heart

Asked and answered....

Queensryche - Operation Mindcrime


Again, your kidding right?
 

narlus

Eastcoast Softcore
Staff member
Nov 7, 2001
24,658
63
behind the viewfinder
no, the only metal records i had in high school were blue oyster cult and that was a bit different from the straight stereotypical metal, mainly due to Richard Meltzer's influence (at least on the 1st 4 or so records). my brother had some kiss, aerosmith and a sabbath record or two (probably some ac/dc and i know he had _double live gonzo_) but i stayed away from the 'heavy metal parking lot' scene. in high school i discovered the simple joys of punk rock, so all that leather posturing was rather silly from my viewpoint.

the 'metal' i've got and listen to now is sludgier, slower stuff. bands like Earth, Sleep, Sunn 0)))) and all their ilk. i still dig sabbath and BOC a lot. the 'mic down the throat' singing style doesn't attract me to any of the new metal stuff (w/ the exception of High on Fire; _Blessed Black Wings_ is a pretty decent record).
 

H8R

Cranky Pants
Nov 10, 2004
13,959
35
sirknight6 said:
OK, I'll give ya that...BUT, what is you opinion of my selections...
I think Udo vs. Phil would be a pretty good match...

:think:
 

DirtyDog

Gang probed by the Golden Banana
Aug 2, 2005
6,598
0
H8R said:
I think Udo vs. Phil would be a pretty good match...

:think:
2 things:

1. If you are going to crash our party tomorrow night, don't bring your dumbass friends.

2. Do you think you have it in you to win a game of KOTH?
 

skinny mike

Turbo Monkey
Jan 24, 2005
6,415
0
im just gonna list a bunch of good metal bands since i usually have no favorite albums for most stuff. in no particular order:
slayer
metallica
black sabbath
17 year tragedy(not emo like the name suggests. you can check them out here.
iron maiden
ac/dc
gnr
im pretty sure ratm isnt metal but they are still damn good and they seem to be about as metal as sod at times
and there are probably some other bands which i dont remember
 

MisterClean

Monkey
Jan 20, 2006
436
0
SoCal Supermarket Shelves
My favorite Heavy Metal is by song instead of album. Sure, there are many
great albums out there, but I feel that certain individual songs from my
earlier years set the stage for what was to be. These seminal songs all
helped Heavy Metal along in one form or another:

My Generation - The Who

Think about 1964 and listen to this song. When teens in the USA were
being fed Pat Boone and other poppy garbage, The Who were blowing the roofs
off of venues and smashing the crap out of their equipment everywhere they
went. Pete Townsend brought feedback into the limelight with this
particular tune.


Stroll On - The Yardbirds

Jeff Beck and Jimmy Page jamming on a song that was later covered by
Aerosmith as "Train Kept A Rollin". Their dual lead guitar attack was
followed by many, most notably Judas Priest in the early years of Metal.


VooDoo Chile (Slight Return) - The Jimi Hendrix Experience

Not acknowledging Jimi's influence on what was to become Metal would be
ridiculous. VooDoo Chile is the heaviest of his early offerings, running
the full gamut of guitar virtuosity.


Journey To The Center Of The Mind - The Amboy Dukes

The first recording with any airplay that featured a young Ted Nugent on
guitar. Ted's playing on this song goes way beyond the psychedelic title.
Also, the "galloping" beat of this song was adopted by many who followed in
other early stages of the Metal genre.


Dazed And Confused - Led Zeppelin

Not the heaviest of Led Zeppelin's offerings, but definitely the anthemic
knockout punch ending to side one of their first album.


Helter Skelter - The Beatles

Who would have thought a song about kids playing on a slide could be so
heavy? Heavy enough to be misinterpreted and adopted by one of the USA's
most notorious psycho killers of all time, Charlie Manson.


Born To Be Wild - Steppenwolf

The lyrics, "Heavy metal thunder". Nuff said there.

Bad Motor Scooter - Montrose

Ronnie Montrose making his guitar sound like a speeding motorcycle going
through the gears and being backed by Sammy Hagar was very heavy for its
time. A fast-paced early offering in the genre by a band that cut two great
albums, "Montrose" and "Paper Money".


Burn - Deep Purple

Smoke On The Water was heavy, but Burn was incendiary. Ritchie Blackmore
showing why he was so successful with DP and Rainbow, the latter featuring
Ronnie James Dio.


Modern Times Rock N Roll - Queen

Yeah, Queen! If you have never heard this song, don't squack about this
selection. For 1973, it covers all of the early metal bases with a very
heavy beat/sound and Brian May completely shredding on the Red Special
guitar that he and his dad built from scratch.


Iron Man - Black Sabbath

There's even Metal in the title! I could probably name two dozen Sabbath
songs that were just as important, but how many of those other songs were
the first riff learned by so many burgeoning metal guitar players?


Back In The Saddle - Aerosmith

A great heavy twist on an old cowboy song written by Gene Autry. I feel
it's one of Aerosmith's heaviest. Appropriately on their "Rocks" LP.


The Green Manalishi - Judas Priest (from "Unleashed In The East")

Rob and the boys, shredding through what Fleetwood Mac's Peter Green made
famous with his own fretboard magic years before. The Priest is hard, heavy
and live on this last offering before the more commercially successful and
critically acclaimed "British Steel".


If You Want Blood (You Got It) - ACDC

Hard rockin' tune from Angus and the boys from Down Under while Bonn
Scott was still out front. Though overshadowed by the title track of
"Highway To Hell", it was good enough for ACDC to name their first live LP
after it.


Lights Out - UFO

Michael Schenker was the lead guitar player for the Scorpions until UFO
stole him away after borrowing his talents for a show their regular guitar
player didn't show for. I find this the most important song by them not
only because it was their biggest commercial success, but because it kicks
butt. The "galloping" bass was brought back by Pete Way, which admittedly
helped influence the style of Iron Maiden's Pete Harris.


The Zoo - Scorpions

I still can't figure out why so many label the Scorps as a "hair band".
Yeah, they went a little poppy later, but why forget their great earlier
offerings? The Zoo is heavy, period. The ga-gunk ga-gunk ga-gunk guitar
sound, though not very fast paced on this track, is still used to this day
in Metal.


Running Free - Iron Maiden

From their debut, self-titled album. Even though Paul Di'Anno only
lasted for two albums with IM, Running Free has lived on and is still a
concert favorite of the Iron Maiden faithful.
 

SK6

Turbo Monkey
Jul 10, 2001
7,586
0
Shut up and ride...
MisterClean said:
My favorite Heavy Metal is by song instead of album. Sure, there are many
great albums out there, but I feel that certain individual songs from my
earlier years set the stage for what was to be. These seminal songs all
helped Heavy Metal along in one form or another:

My Generation - The Who

Think about 1964 and listen to this song. When teens in the USA were
being fed Pat Boone and other poppy garbage, The Who were blowing the roofs
off of venues and smashing the crap out of their equipment everywhere they
went. Pete Townsend brought feedback into the limelight with this
particular tune.


Stroll On - The Yardbirds

Jeff Beck and Jimmy Page jamming on a song that was later covered by
Aerosmith as "Train Kept A Rollin". Their dual lead guitar attack was
followed by many, most notably Judas Priest in the early years of Metal.


VooDoo Chile (Slight Return) - The Jimi Hendrix Experience

Not acknowledging Jimi's influence on what was to become Metal would be
ridiculous. VooDoo Chile is the heaviest of his early offerings, running
the full gamut of guitar virtuosity.


Journey To The Center Of The Mind - The Amboy Dukes

The first recording with any airplay that featured a young Ted Nugent on
guitar. Ted's playing on this song goes way beyond the psychedelic title.
Also, the "galloping" beat of this song was adopted by many who followed in
other early stages of the Metal genre.


Dazed And Confused - Led Zeppelin

Not the heaviest of Led Zeppelin's offerings, but definitely the anthemic
knockout punch ending to side one of their first album.


Helter Skelter - The Beatles

Who would have thought a song about kids playing on a slide could be so
heavy? Heavy enough to be misinterpreted and adopted by one of the USA's
most notorious psycho killers of all time, Charlie Manson.


Born To Be Wild - Steppenwolf

The lyrics, "Heavy metal thunder". Nuff said there.

Bad Motor Scooter - Montrose

Ronnie Montrose making his guitar sound like a speeding motorcycle going
through the gears and being backed by Sammy Hagar was very heavy for its
time. A fast-paced early offering in the genre by a band that cut two great
albums, "Montrose" and "Paper Money".


Burn - Deep Purple

Smoke On The Water was heavy, but Burn was incendiary. Ritchie Blackmore
showing why he was so successful with DP and Rainbow, the latter featuring
Ronnie James Dio.


Modern Times Rock N Roll - Queen

Yeah, Queen! If you have never heard this song, don't squack about this
selection. For 1973, it covers all of the early metal bases with a very
heavy beat/sound and Brian May completely shredding on the Red Special
guitar that he and his dad built from scratch.


Iron Man - Black Sabbath

There's even Metal in the title! I could probably name two dozen Sabbath
songs that were just as important, but how many of those other songs were
the first riff learned by so many burgeoning metal guitar players?


Back In The Saddle - Aerosmith

A great heavy twist on an old cowboy song written by Gene Autry. I feel
it's one of Aerosmith's heaviest. Appropriately on their "Rocks" LP.


The Green Manalishi - Judas Priest (from "Unleashed In The East")

Rob and the boys, shredding through what Fleetwood Mac's Peter Green made
famous with his own fretboard magic years before. The Priest is hard, heavy
and live on this last offering before the more commercially successful and
critically acclaimed "British Steel".


If You Want Blood (You Got It) - ACDC

Hard rockin' tune from Angus and the boys from Down Under while Bonn
Scott was still out front. Though overshadowed by the title track of
"Highway To Hell", it was good enough for ACDC to name their first live LP
after it.


Lights Out - UFO

Michael Schenker was the lead guitar player for the Scorpions until UFO
stole him away after borrowing his talents for a show their regular guitar
player didn't show for. I find this the most important song by them not
only because it was their biggest commercial success, but because it kicks
butt. The "galloping" bass was brought back by Pete Way, which admittedly
helped influence the style of Iron Maiden's Pete Harris.


The Zoo - Scorpions

I still can't figure out why so many label the Scorps as a "hair band".
Yeah, they went a little poppy later, but why forget their great earlier
offerings? The Zoo is heavy, period. The ga-gunk ga-gunk ga-gunk guitar
sound, though not very fast paced on this track, is still used to this day
in Metal.


Running Free - Iron Maiden

From their debut, self-titled album. Even though Paul Di'Anno only
lasted for two albums with IM, Running Free has lived on and is still a
concert favorite of the Iron Maiden faithful.

All very good choices. :thumb:
 

Zark

Hey little girl, do you want some candy?
Oct 18, 2001
6,254
7
Reno 911
KNine said:
I have to go old school here also.

5.Venom-At War With Satan
4.Death Angel- The Ultraviolence
3.Testament-The New Order
2.Nuclear Assault-Survive
1.Slayer-Hell Awaits
+2points for obscurity. Nuclear Assault and Death Angel are way off the radar to most people

Last night I put in Kreator, Coma of Souls. Ahh nothing like relaxing to the sounds of soothing German speed metal:p
 

SK6

Turbo Monkey
Jul 10, 2001
7,586
0
Shut up and ride...
Zark said:
+2points for obscurity. Nuclear Assault and Death Angel are way off the radar to most people

Last night I put in Kreator, Coma of Souls. Ahh nothing like relaxing to the sounds of soothing German speed metal:p
I have to laugh since we used to play in the same circls of clubs...Nuclear Assault were cool as hell and WAY before their time.

Death Angel, just rocks. I saw them in concert before many of the members of this board were born...:p
 

H8R

Cranky Pants
Nov 10, 2004
13,959
35
Hellhammer - Apocalyptic Raids
Celtic Frost - To Mega Therion
Nitro - O.F.R.
Obsessed - The Church Within
 

narlus

Eastcoast Softcore
Staff member
Nov 7, 2001
24,658
63
behind the viewfinder
some of my personal favorites:

helmet - strap it on
blue oyster cult - on yr feet or on yr knees
black sabbath - black sabbath
burzum - filosefem
melvins - stoner witch