Quantcast

assisted suicide

911

Monkey
Feb 28, 2002
275
0
Vail CO
Beats me... if someone is in sound mental condition, then it should be their decision whether they want to live or not.
 

BurlyShirley

Rex Grossman Will Rise Again
Jul 4, 2002
19,180
17
TN
I dont mind the concept, but people are stupid about it. How is it that you need assistance? Just drink some clorox or something or jump off the roof of the nursing home.
 

BuddhaRoadkill

I suck at Tool
Feb 15, 2004
988
0
Chintimini Bog
BurlySurly said:
I dont mind the concept, but people are stupid about it. How is it that you need assistance? Just drink some clorox or something or jump off the roof of the nursing home.
Apparently you don't understand the concept. Assisted suicide is for those that are unable to off themselves. Terminally ill, bed ridden, can't wipe your own ass kinda thing [but mentally sound :rolleyes:]. And therein lies the dilemma - someone else has to kill you. Other than horsesh1t religious arguments, the main con is a slippery slope of abuse and manipulation. The scenario:
You have lots of money and your kids are evil. Although you are normally a happy go lucky fella, they whisper nasty nothings in your ear until your esteem and confidence is such a wreck you just want to die. ... and if the nasty nothings don't work, your evil children might somehow force you to sign the death warrant by threatening your favorite Chihuahua or some such diabolical plan. [It really makes you wonder about the family lives of the rich and powerfull is this is the kind of arguments they throw out :nopity:]
There is also great concern that people will make a bad decision simply because they are depressed. Well ... their terminally ill for christ sake - of course they are depressed.

:mumble:/
We in Oregon have voted for this right not once, but twice. We've even had our Republican Sen. Gordon Smith vote against us [limit gov't my ass]. And now Ashcroft wants the federalese to overide. I guess states rights only applies to the racist god-fearing bible belt.
end :mumble://

Soilent Green is people .... :blah: