Quantcast

how about a car audio thread?

binary visions

The voice of reason
Jun 13, 2002
22,151
1,253
NC
at that price....let the fat lady continue serenading you.

a $100 dollar upgrade won't sound much better.
I completely disagree.

The stock speakers blow, and virtually any upgrade, especially a $100 upgrade, will sound substantially better.

I've still got the Polks mentioned in this thread from 2004, they sound a whole lot better than the stock junkers.
 

Kanye West

220# bag of hacktastic
Aug 31, 2006
3,767
501
An additional upgrade that is well worth its money, both in audio quality and general sound quality of the car is installing some sort of sound deadening medium into the door panels, floor, and ceiling of the cab. You can go really overboard with it too, but a little bit will go a long way, and can be done very cheap.
 

nauc

Monkey
May 14, 2007
475
3
i'm gonna start upgrading the stock system in my Tacoma, and am kinda wondering which direction i should take. i've got about $400 to spend right now, so should i:

- get a headunit now, and replace the speakers around X-Mas time, then go for an amp and sub.

- get speakers now, headunit around X-Mas, sub and amp last.

- something else?

my stock stuff is fine, it's just getting a little old, and i'm wanting a cleaner sound. i'm not after thumps, i want crisp, pure sound.

headunits i'm looking at are Pioneers, Sonys, and Alpines, in the $300 range. i had a Pioneer a while ago, back when 35W/channel was good. loved it. then got a Sony with Active Black Panel. loved it, too, but it got jacked.

don't know what to do with speakers. i'm lost in that area. i just know i want a set of components. someone want to toss up some ideas?

:thumb:
id get a new deck now, then speakers, then amps and sub

i have the 9887, love it. you can get it for under $300 off ebay

http://www.alpine-usa.com/US-en/products/product.php?model=CDA-9887

these are nice for the $ http://www.woofersetc.com/p6201/CTX65CS--Image-Dynamics-65"-Component-Speaker-System.htm

or some CDTs

couple Alpine amps and a RE sub, yould be good to go
 

nauc

Monkey
May 14, 2007
475
3
Alpine back in the day was sold only in specialty stores, they weren't mass produced as they are today. Now you can walk into a Good Guys, Circuit City etc, and they are all selling them. Its been a few years since I was really into car audio, I had a system worth over $5K back in 1989 then again this is when CD players were really just comming out and my head unit was $1200 and the lower end one at the time was atound $699 or so. As far as really good sounding players right now I still like Eclipse and Nakamichi. However if your just throwing in a player for tunes, I'm sure the Alpine will be fine.
times have changed, big time since then. now you can get 24 Bit DAC Alpines with 2 or 3 way 1st thru 4th order digital xovers, with 6 channels of delay, with peqs and geqs and Bluetooth and HD Radio for under $300. they dont sound like the F1s or McIntosh decks but theyre not 2-3gs either and they do still sound damn nice.
 
Last edited:

Dog Welder

Turbo Monkey
Sep 7, 2001
1,123
0
Pasadena, CA
How good is older equipment? I stll have a 10 year old Eclipse amp and sub in another vehicle that I was thinking about salvaging. Has there been enough advancement in the last decade to warrrant buying a new amp and sub?
 

manimal

Ociffer Tackleberry
Feb 27, 2002
7,213
22
Blindly running into cactus
i just snagged this last night for my beater subie. http://www.6ave.com/shop/product.aspx?ref=Froogle&sku=JENHD5313

i've gone for 3 years now with only aux input (external mp3 player, usually via my phone) because the stock antenna plug wasn't long enough and,frankly, i didn't care. i've got a 500w fosgate amp pushing a 10" sub (bought the pair for $35 from a friend) and generic box 6" speakers to replace the dry rotted stock hatchback 6x9's.

adding an inexpensive HD radio made a world of a difference. my old head unit hardly worked and i had to tap it with my fist to get all the speakers to work. the HD channels are super clear and loud and the face isn't too busy so i can find what i'm looking for while driving. i'm digging the SD card slot as i shouldn't have to hook up my phone to the aux port if all of my tunes are on the card in the head unit.
for $100...i'm not complaining :D and i installed it in a record 1.5 hours :thumb: you audiophiles would crack up if you saw my jerry rig job of additional speakers in the front. the door speaker wires quit working so i just installed an aftermarket speaker in paneling underneath the steering column...looks professional and sounds good too ;)
 

Toshi

butthole powerwashing evangelist
Oct 23, 2001
39,457
8,537
IH8rice or any other car audio monkies want to chime in on these sketched out ideas?



I'm not even sure if that last setup would work (2 way active front components, passive coaxials in the rear, sub), although post #13 here suggests it is possible… This **** is confusing.
 
Last edited:

vinnycactus

Monkey
May 27, 2004
653
94
Matthews, NC
I saw this thread come up from about 3 years ago. I had I funny quip as a retort. I then realized Toshi brought it back up. I then realized he's a doctor. I then realized he's much smarter than me. I then realized I've been drinking. I then realized I don't post much and I may be chastised. But regardless, here's my $0.02. Buy a new car with upgraded sound. I preface this by saying Toshi as well as the majority of RM is much smarter than me, and I've been drinking. Please continue with your day.

-Regards
 

Toshi

butthole powerwashing evangelist
Oct 23, 2001
39,457
8,537
I'm all about the necro- and obsessive-topic-updates-over-half-a-decade bumps. :D
 

vinnycactus

Monkey
May 27, 2004
653
94
Matthews, NC
I'm all about the necro- and obsessive-topic-updates-over-half-a-decade bumps. :D
I dig it. I will say that we've bout vehicles solely on they're audio/bluetooth capabilities.

That being said, I have nothing else to add. I will continue drinking garbage beer.
 
Last edited:

bean

Turbo Monkey
Feb 16, 2004
1,335
0
Boulder
It's a bit of a taste thing. Do you like rear fill?

I don't and always turn down the rear speakers unless someone else is in the back seat. So I'd go with option two.
 

Toshi

butthole powerwashing evangelist
Oct 23, 2001
39,457
8,537
I've never been in any quality built up vehicles, let alone enough of them to know if I like rear fill or not. My experience was just my ****ty WRX system build from 2005 (coax x 4 doors off of one amp, direct iPod input to said amp, iirc) + spending time in the local shop's speaker auditioning room back then.
 

vinnycactus

Monkey
May 27, 2004
653
94
Matthews, NC
Ok, half drunk review. I currently have a Toyota Venza with JBL door mounts throughout. Up to mid-range is really good, over that is hollow. Prior, I had a Nissan Titan that had factory Harmon Cardon with a sub under the driver seat. Best system I've had. Both were factory systems.

This doesn't add much. But I feel the need for punching chicklettes.
 

4xBoy

Turbo Monkey
Jun 20, 2006
7,169
3,136
Minneapolis
I have a 05 Silverado, CD doesn't work, what deck can take music off my droid and use my steering wheel controls?
 

dan-o

Turbo Monkey
Jun 30, 2004
6,499
2,805
A car moving down the road with mechanical, wind, road, noise in a small enclosed metal box. Save your money...
JD is on track here, imo.

My truck has the 'premium' bose system in it. Sitting in the driveway its fine though it has its limitations.
Once moving the diesel clatter, turbo whine, tire rumble and usually down windows all conspire to make the audio experience a **** show of ambient noise overlayed by music.

The benz has a great sounding factory HK system in it.
Being a wagon though, even with excellent sound deadening, road noise at hwy speeds again make me doubt that spending more would improve audio at tolerable volume levels.

Subarus are noisy, tinny vehicles (I've had 3) and would be the last brand I've invest heavily into audio in.
I'd also get the best factory head unit and build a system off that.
No need to attract attention at the trailhead or in the city with an aftermarket unit.

*Disclaimer: I've always felt that car audio and the high-volume, parking lot cock-fests that surround it, was the most retarded of all automotive modifications. IMO, the best factory systems are likely the most sensible choice as they've been optimized/integrated into the interior to a reasonable level of quality given the compromised environment.
 

IH8Rice

I'm Mr. Negative! I Fail!
Aug 2, 2008
24,524
494
Im over here now
IH8rice or any other car audio monkies want to chime in on these sketched out ideas?



I'm not even sure if that last setup would work (2 way active front components, passive coaxials in the rear, sub), although post #13 here suggests it is possible… This **** is confusing.
they would all work and any of them of them would be fine to go with. when designing a system, i typically look at how much do you want to spend, how much work you want to do, where the speakers are located/vehicle type/how much space for equipment...

my truck's sound system is set up pretty similar to the last one on your list: eclipse pre-amp headunit w/ a larger eq/x-over, Focal front components bi-amped by a JL 300/4, rear Focal components on a JL 300/2 and two 13.5" JL subs running on two JL 500/1 amps.

if i was to do another setup, i would go the route of "option 2" on your list. the front sound stage is the most important imo (the rears could/would still add presence tho,) so having the 4 channel amp work those two speakers would sound great. if you wanted to geek out just a bit more, you could replace the rears with a coax and just run them off the headunit, not an external amp. a 5 channel amp would still be sufficient for this setup.
 

Toshi

butthole powerwashing evangelist
Oct 23, 2001
39,457
8,537
if i was to do another setup, i would go the route of "option 2" on your list. the front sound stage is the most important imo (the rears could/would still add presence tho,) so having the 4 channel amp work those two speakers would sound great. if you wanted to geek out just a bit more, you could replace the rears with a coax and just run them off the headunit, not an external amp. a 5 channel amp would still be sufficient for this setup.
Thanks for the tips, all. I am cognizant that cars are suboptimal listening platforms.

IH8Rice: Preouts + deck power can be active simultaneously? I like this last idea, maybe even with the stock rear speakers. I'd probably screw around with limiting the frequencies going to the back +/- delaying it if the head unit can do that.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haas_effect
 

IH8Rice

I'm Mr. Negative! I Fail!
Aug 2, 2008
24,524
494
Im over here now
IH8Rice: Preouts + deck power can be active simultaneously? I like this last idea, maybe even with the stock rear speakers
Unless radios have changed a lot since I last remember, then yes. Ths radio doesn't know if something is actually connected to the preouts. Some radios do have the option to shut the internal amp off to help with sound quality but only the higher ends units had this feature.
Time delay does help. It took me a bit to dial mine in but it cars with bad speaker placement, it'll help
 
Last edited:

Uncle Cliffy

Turbo Monkey
Jan 28, 2008
4,490
42
Southern Oregon
IMO, the best factory systems are likely the most sensible choice as they've been optimized/integrated into the interior to a reasonable level of quality given the compromised environment.
Fairly true.

Problem is, most automobile insulation/sound deadening from the factory is sub-par at best. Making a car quiet, and free from ambient road noise is the foundation of a good system.
 

jimmydean

The Official Meat of Ridemonkey
Sep 10, 2001
42,795
14,880
Portland, OR
Thanks for the tips, all. I am cognizant that cars are suboptimal listening platforms.

IH8Rice: Preouts + deck power can be active simultaneously? I like this last idea, maybe even with the stock rear speakers. I'd probably screw around with limiting the frequencies going to the back +/- delaying it if the head unit can do that.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haas_effect
I am running my front dash speakers off deck power with my rear speakers and door speakers tied off the front channel of my 4 channel amp with the sub ran bridged off the rear channel of the amp.

<edit>
I did put a high pass filter on the dash speakers to reduce the bass (4" don't have much bottom end).
 
Last edited:

Toshi

butthole powerwashing evangelist
Oct 23, 2001
39,457
8,537
Cool. Good to know it can be done. Can't do time alignment on that non-channel, though. I think I'd stick with straight up option 2 (sans rear speakers) or option 3 (all singing and dancing 4 way active crossover).

With regard to stock stereos: Unless I lose all sense of modesty and actually spring for a luxury car with a truly high end system (e.g. Mark Levinson in Lexuses) then I don't think the factory upgraded stereos would be enough to satisfy my #firstworldproblem needs wants.

We have the JBL system in the Prius, for instance, replete with A pillar mounted tweeters, and it lacks the oomph for big orchestral works like Alpine Symphony. (Sounds fine with the 6 dB-of-dynamic-range top 40 crap on the radio, on the other hand.)
 

jimmydean

The Official Meat of Ridemonkey
Sep 10, 2001
42,795
14,880
Portland, OR
One thing my system needs is an active crossover that I will add eventually and may add a separate bass amp. Currently I am using the built in (non adjustable) HP/LP amp settings, but need the ability to dial in the crossover points. The door speakers do have passive crossovers as well (6.5 + tweet separates).

Doors before:


Doors now (ignore tape on tweet):


Back before:


Back after (need to get a pic with the tool box in place)


The dash 4x6's were replaced with 4" round 2 ways, the rear 4x6's were replaced with 4x6 2 ways.

Old vs new:


This setup was done on the wicked cheap using sale pieces and a pawn shop amp for less than $250. The old ass Panasonic deck was already in the truck, but has RCA shielding issues and a crap receiver. It will be replaced eventually.
 

HardtailHack

used an iron once
Jan 20, 2009
7,544
6,885
Yeah active three way front, do it. I had active three way in my last car and it was horrible but that was because of bad speaker selection and buying overpriced American made ****! I am now running a passive three way front stage with a 4" mid at dash height on axis which means all of the vocals are up high which helped imaging greatly.

My previous car's big downfall was running a two inch mid which meant that a lot of important musical info went to the woofers in the door and it sounded crap and no time alignment would get a result I was happy with.

In my opinion if you are going to keep factory(ish) speaker locations time alignment and a good EQ are an absolute must if you want the vocals to come from centre of the windscreen. My current install was done on a crazy tight budget and the only item that wasn't secondhand was the HU and I am really happy with the results.

If you go to all this effort please don't skimp on deadening it makes a massive difference.
 

stevew

resident influencer
Sep 21, 2001
41,063
10,016
i prefer that people keep their music to themselves when driving....
 

HardtailHack

used an iron once
Jan 20, 2009
7,544
6,885
Usually people that assemble a system like Toshi would like to aren't really the type drive round windows down stereo up.

People who buy loud stereos are like people who buy good bikes and can't ride, it's just to show off to people in parking lots.
 

kazlx

Patches O'Houlihan
Aug 7, 2006
6,985
1,958
Tustin, CA
Pretty easy to put together budget systems that will kill most 'high end factory systems'. IMO most of them sound like poop. It's surprising, even to non-audio geeks what even an amp, a small sub and a decent set of speakers can do.
 

Toshi

butthole powerwashing evangelist
Oct 23, 2001
39,457
8,537
Pretty easy to put together budget systems that will kill most 'high end factory systems'. IMO most of them sound like poop. It's surprising, even to non-audio geeks what even an amp, a small sub and a decent set of speakers can do.
doubtful...especially if its a legitimate high end factory system.
That's the key word. Most systems aren't what they advertise.
Ok, I'll bite. Which systems pass muster, in your opinion?

The Mark Levinson Reference Sound system found in the LS and LX lines? The Bang & Olufsen Advanced Sound System found in the A8? The Bowers & Wilkens systems found in Maserati and Jaguar cars? Harmon & Kardon Logic 7 in the various Mercs and BMWs? Lexicon's Logic 7 system in the Equus?

Some of these systems look like they're after immersion and speaker count above all else, I suppose, but those are big names that wouldn't whore themselves out too easily… I'd hope.
 

DirtyMike

Turbo Fluffer
Aug 8, 2005
14,437
1,017
My own world inside my head
Personally..... There are an amazing amount of different ways to go to get the same result....

Check on my Mommy mobile<expedition> Walmart brand Dual head unit, pushing a 70 amp per channel on an eight speaker system, upgraded the speakers to infiniti's, and sony explode 10 in subin a sealed downshot box, carpeted to match the interior with an 800 watt blaupunkt amp....... Perfect clarity through out all volume ranges.



Now, I can remove my windows and yours should I desire to, but I listen at a normal level, I like my hearing, but I also spoil myself with music, I like clear and precise music. Now one of my favorite things is when the damn dumbass kids rolls up next to me in his honda bumping 5K watts into a 15 in brain exploding sub setup with stock everything else......... I look over and they think they kick ass...... then I roll up the volume on some slipknot, or hatebreed, or luke bryan something like that and just blow there **** system away.....
 

kazlx

Patches O'Houlihan
Aug 7, 2006
6,985
1,958
Tustin, CA
Ok, I'll bite. Which systems pass muster, in your opinion?
Some of these systems look like they're after immersion and speaker count above all else, I suppose, but those are big names that wouldn't whore themselves out too easily&#8230; I'd hope.
I'm not impressed with my buddies' brand new CLS550. I think most of the companies are getting wrapped up in speaker count instead of actual sound quality. Have you listened to any that knock your socks off? I don't think I have ever got in a brand new car and been surprised in a good way. I was actually disappointed in the CLS...
 

DirtyMike

Turbo Fluffer
Aug 8, 2005
14,437
1,017
My own world inside my head
I'm not impressed with my buddies' brand new CLS550. I think most of the companies are getting wrapped up in speaker count instead of actual sound quality. Have you listened to any that knock your socks off? I don't think I have ever got in a brand new car and been surprised in a good way. I was actually disappointed in the CLS...
The new Chevrolet premium sound packages are good, and the one that will surprise you in the Kia premium sound system.