I just about spit Gatorade all over my screen when I read this............LOLSkookum said:Ok who wants to place bet that Andyman will "save" Changleen and will grow to love George Bush Jr. and love America. 300 to 1 odds.
Since my story is rather involved, and it's late here, I'll post it tomorrow.Changleen said:OK, Cool. I would like to read the story, especially a) wrt your schooling and b) especially the bit where you (if you?) decided religion was the most important thing in your life.
I promise I won't disect your logic. I might ask questions. But then I want to talk about Aliens.
Silver said:If there's no god, then we may not have freewill either. The jury's out on that one as well.
So what would be the difference between a member of your postulated advanced species and God?Changleen said:I think that the possibility of a advanced species being responsible for the creation of the universe is far more likely than any of your 'god' theories.
It's been a while since I read much science on the start of the universe (quantum realities bent my mind a little bit on a plane from Spain one time) but you are implying that time has a starting point. That begs the question of how it could be measured and identified and from whence did it appear?Changleen said:Current Science seems to suggest there is a 'starting' point for our universe as we understand it, so it seems reasonable to assume that something initiated that start, or else the universe is in some way cyclic? Even if it is cyclic, does it not seem likely that the cycle itself had to be brought about at some point?
I would agree that this supposed 'creator' obviously doesn't give a monkeys about the inhabitants of this universe - which leads me to think that the universe itself must serve some kind of function for someone. Maybe we're just the particles in the explosion in some vast extra-cosmic heat engine...
Andyman, do you believe that humanity is the only life in the universe?
I'm not Andyman, but I believe in cats and dogs too.Changleen said:Andyman, do you believe that humanity is the only life in the universe?
You can always just throw in useless gems like this.binary visions said:Anyhow.. I'm interested in your story too, Andyman. I'm afraid I have little to add to these discussions which is why I don't participate, but I do read them with great interest!
No their isn't , after all even the contemporary nutjobs sometimes get a following, no doubt even ancient history is littered with nutjobs who failed to convince anyone.Westy said:You can always just throw in useless gems like this.
How come today when people claim to talk to god we call them nutjobs but many people base their lives off of people who claimed to speak with god a few thousand years ago. Is their really any difference?
Exactly, tiz a waste of time to seriously sit and ponder. No one knows, even those who say they know dont friggin know, just like burly doesnt know and I dont friggin know. We cant prove god and we cant disprove god. The concept of god is so abstract and so diverse... I'm willing to venture that God as a singular being doesn't exist. I think man/we by our own nature invented god because we couldnt explain the world around us nor could we accept the idea of nothingness. The only thing that makes any sense to me is that there is no heaven or no concious afterlife, when we die there is some kind of a total loss of self yet some part of you still exists in the universe... I dont know anything though, of course, and I dont claim anything and I wont follow anyone that says he/she knows anything because they dont. Maybe I'll be just gone when I die and it wont matter to me anyway because I wont be able to give a sh!t that my whole live was just a short ride in a universe who's point I'll never understand. Then again, maybe I'll see the pearly gates and those guys will flush me to hell for joining their club and then bailing on them when I couldnt wrap my fingers around their wacked out mumbo jumbo concepts and contradictory philosophies.Westy said:My theory is that humans are incapable of understanding the true concept of god unless there is really no such thing, so it is pretty much useless for us to discuss it unless we want to talk about the nothingness of god.
I wouldn't say it is a waste of time to think about and I probably went to far in saying it shouldn't be discussed. Man has an built in need to find answers to things and we should look for those answers, but since you can never know what the true answer is it is the journey that makes it worthwile not the endpoint. Too many people just like to pull a boxed set of answers off a shelf and skip the journey, and most importantly take it all way too seriously.golgiaparatus said:Exactly, tiz a waste of time to seriously sit and ponder. No one knows, even those who say they know dont friggin know, just like burly doesnt know and I dont friggin know. We cant prove god and we cant disprove god. The concept of god is so abstract and so diverse... I'm willing to venture that God as a singular being doesn't exist. I think man/we by our own nature invented god because we couldnt explain the world around us nor could we accept the idea of nothingness. The only thing that makes any sense to me is that there is no heaven or no concious afterlife, when we die there is some kind of a total loss of self. I dont know anything though, maybe I'll be just gone when I die and it wont matter to me anyway because I wont be able to give a sh!t that my whole live was just a short ride in a universe who's point I'll never understand. Then again, maybe I'll see the pearly gates and those guys will flush me to hell for joining their club and then bailing on them when I couldnt wrap my fingers around their wacked out mumbo jumbo concepts and contradictory philosophies.
This thread is neaky:
Its because a lot of people take it way to personal. Someone showed them what to believe and made god a personal so they defend God like they would defend their mother. Also some people, I think, really get offended because they are afraid of an unknown/uncertain afterlife. I have no problem if someone bashes anything I have to say as long as they admit they have as much a grasp on the reality of their concepts as I do on mine, which is to say very little.Westy said:Too many people just like to pull a boxed set of answers off a shelf and skip the journey, and most importantly take it all way too seriously.
Ridemonkey said:How is it you subscribe to an array of nonsensical conservative issues without being one of Gods devoted followers?
Advanced species never came here and laid down any moral laws, parted any seas etc, and doesn't give a **** about you or your insignificant, pointless life.fluff said:So what would be the difference between a member of your postulated advanced species and God?
Yes, That is correct. Current theory states that time and space are in fact one and the same, two directions on the same plane if you want to think of it in 2 dimensions. That is why you have probably heard it referred to as Spacetime, or the Spacetime continuum. This part of the argument is pretty much beyond doubt, it has much measurable evidence to back it up. The second part is fairly well accepted, but still open to question: Spacetime (as we know it) only existed after the big bang (which there is ever increasing evidence for) - what is not really that well known, obviously, is what happened before the big bang. That's where we might find our 'god' or whatever.fluff said:but you are implying that time has a starting point. That begs the question of how it could be measured and identified and from whence did it appear?
Yeah Golgia, thinking about this stuff is fun. Especially when you read about quantum physics and spend ages trying to get your head around thinking in 4 (or 11/12) dimensions. It's very humbling and fulfilling at the same time.Westy said:I wouldn't say it is a waste of time to think about and I probably went to far in saying it shouldn't be discussed. Man has an built in need to find answers to things and we should look for those answers, but since you can never know what the true answer is it is the journey that makes it worthwile not the endpoint. Too many people just like to pull a boxed set of answers off a shelf and skip the journey, and most importantly take it all way too seriously.
Thanks Chang for your kind words, I appreciate the tone of the discussion we have had on this thread.Changleen said:Wow, That's an amazing story Andy. Sounds like you went through a borderline crazy stage there for a while, but well done for getting it together again. I'm glad you're still around so the can benefit from your input. (How selfish.)
I will say as time goes on the more I struggle internally with the whole startin the whole church thing. I want to make sure I'm doing it for the right reasons and not so I can have an ego trip every Sunday with people telling me how good I am. I think, unfortunatly I'm going to bump into a "glass ceiling" of sorts with the fact I've not been to seminary (which curiously rhymes with cemetary......LOL).Changleen said:Maybe you should start your own church. Your idea of 'god' (from what I've read at least' seems somewhat different to the classic beardy angry white guy, which I suppose is positive. I just hope you keep exploring, and maybe explore some science at some point. I don't think your idea of god is 100% incompatible with 'hard science' - there's certainly a lot of 'unknown' space out there. Plenty for a non-vengefull beardy white guy anyway.
Thanks for the story.
Andyman_1970 said:As for God sitting in heaven with a beard and lighting bolts waiting to zap people, that's certainly not a concept of the Judeo/Christian God I know and study.
Quit thinking about the Judeo Christian God and think about God as a concept and your advanced species looks no different. Stop thinking in straight lines for Advanced Specie's sake!Changleen said:Advanced species never came here and laid down any moral laws, parted any seas etc, and doesn't give a **** about you or your insignificant, pointless life.
Within the life of this universe yes, but outside of that? And we will never find 'god'. We will theorise but we can never prove, unless of course you invent time travel that goes beyond the start of time...Changleen said:Yes, That is correct. Current theory states that time and space are in fact one and the same, two directions on the same plane if you want to think of it in 2 dimensions. That is why you have probably heard it referred to as Spacetime, or the Spacetime continuum. This part of the argument is pretty much beyond doubt, it has much measurable evidence to back it up. The second part is fairly well accepted, but still open to question: Spacetime (as we know it) only existed after the big bang (which there is ever increasing evidence for) - what is not really that well known, obviously, is what happened before the big bang. That's where we might find our 'god' or whatever.
Um, Isn't that what we were doing? Seriously. You aren't taking in what's being said very well today.fluff said:Quit thinking about the Judeo Christian God and think about God as a concept and your advanced species looks no different. Stop thinking in straight lines for Advanced Specie's sake!
It's what you're doing. The thread title even has the word concept in it you knucklehead!Changleen said:Um, Isn't that what we were doing? Seriously. You aren't taking in what's being said very well today.
...Make it a bit clearer then, eh? And I thoroughly object to being called a chav, you pikey.fluff said:It's what you're doing. The thread title even has the word concept in it you knucklehead!
And in the other thread I was talking to N8 you gnat-brained chav!
Good. Now go back to your room.Changleen said:I thoroughly object to being called a chav, you pikey.
Skookum once wrote eloquently: (http://www.ridemonkey.com/forums/showthread.php?p=1266622#post1266622)MikeD said:God is indeed manifest everywhere, and we're not unique. God is as much in/around/a part of us as he is anything else.
MD
I'll check it out..........thanks.MikeD said:Has anyone here (Andy, especially) ever read "Flatland?"
Light, easy read. Looks like it's cheap, too.
When I first skimmed this post, I thought Mike was referring to me as "The rabbi Andy", I was whoa dude you're gonna give me an ego problem........LOLMikeD said:The rabbi Andy mentions sounds a lot like a Buddhist.....
As finite beings ourselves we may never fully know God, but as a part of the totality of God's manifestation through environment, nature and history we may have a glimpse of what the nature of God is.MikeD said:"Flatland". . .it's all about science and human conceptions. . . about the limitations of our knowledge and our paradigms of thinking. I find it, in a way, to be a good expression of what I've been trying to express about how we can never know God, as finite beings ourselves.
. . . God is indeed manifest everywhere, and we're not unique. God is as much in/around/a part of us as he is anything else.
But that's why I don't see God as a super-being with an aspect of agency, in that God 'does' things...I see God 'as' the totality of our environment, I guess.
MD
Can I get an "AMEN"...............yes you sure canenkidu said:The quest for the ultimate peace (of mind, between people, and among nations) and love (unconditional acceptance) is the basic theme of various religions. Can we safely assume that the ultimate peace and love, together with ultimate beauty, truth and goodness, are at the core of the nature of God?
Very well said grasshopper. The meaning and depth of the word "Shalom" in the Hebrew has so had an impact on the spiritual journey of not only myself but my wife as well we named our son Noah - which in Hebrew means "Shalom".enkidu said:By the way, "Shalom" (Hebrew) and "Salaam" (Arabic) are preceded by ancient Sumerian "Silim-ma" (3000 BC - 1800 BC). Patriarch Abraham grew up in ancient Mesopotamia around 1800 BC hearing this greeting of peace, health and wholesomeness used by the common ancestors of Jews and Arabs. Another manifestation of God, perhaps, pointing to the oneness of humans. (In ancient mythical texts this can be written as "Thus God created Adam.")
Andyman_1970 said:... My response was also, God cant use me as messed up as I am and with all the junk Ive done. It was then I found out this Jesus loved me exactly as I was. Regardless of the junk I had in my life, my baggage or whatever...
Binary Visions I think summed up the differences better than I can:bmxr said:I don't claim to be a philosopher, but I do know it doesn't make sense to have to DIS-prove assertions of truth or Truth or whatever. The burden of proof has to fall on the positive assertion, which, in this case is "there is a God". I think, humbly, that "Leap of Faith" is just a simplistic way of saying that science/knowledge has not caught up to the belief/theory being postulated.
Anyway, my story was not an effort for me to convince you to believe as I do, it was a response to a request by Changleen. So as such feel free to agree or disagree with it.Yet no matter how much logic is brought forth, how many text references, and all the good conversation in the world... You'll never bridge that "faith" gap.
Of course, it doesn't mean that they aren't educational discussions or shouldn't be had. It does mean, though, that all the different roads that are traveled down in these discussions all end at the same bridge - and for people like Changleen, the bridge is out. Andyman is on the other side, and nothing can be done; only some experience or leap on Changleen's part will change the situation.
Why must there not be a higher purpose?bmxr said:Why must there be a higher pupose?
According to the Bible you could be used of God and not realize it.bmxr said:Why must I be of use to God, Jesus, .....?
Everyone uses that cop-outChangleen said:Occam's Razor.
You still need to explain "God." When you add God, you take a very complex system and add an infinitely complex layer on top of it. Since you're postulating an infinitely complex being, why not just postulate that chance takes care of it and be done with it?binary visions said:Everyone uses that cop-out
Show me how billions and billions of years of random matter floating around the universe forming complex ecological systems and evolving the human brain out of single-celled organisms by random genetic mutations is a simpler explanation than the existance of God.
Occam's Razor shouldn't even be brought up in theological discussions. I don't believe in Creationism but that doesn't mean that the reason it's wrong is because of Occam's Razor.
Everyone uses your avatar.. So what?binary visions said:Everyone uses that cop-out
It's not. That's the point. God is the cop out here.Show me how billions and billions of years of random matter floating around the universe forming complex ecological systems and evolving the human brain out of single-celled organisms by random genetic mutations is a simpler explanation than the existance of God.
Whatever. I'll bring up what I want.Occam's Razor shouldn't even be brought up in theological discussions. I don't believe in Creationism but that doesn't mean that the reason it's wrong is because of Occam's Razor.
You've also failed to comprehend the reference. Read it again:binary visions said:Everyone uses that cop-out
Show me how billions and billions of years of random matter floating around the universe forming complex ecological systems and evolving the human brain out of single-celled organisms by random genetic mutations is a simpler explanation than the existance of God.
Occam's Razor shouldn't even be brought up in theological discussions. I don't believe in Creationism but that doesn't mean that the reason it's wrong is because of Occam's Razor.
Andy said:Why must there not be a higher purpose?
For there to be a higher purpose for everyone all worked out, there has to be something even more complex than "billions and billions of years of random matter floating around the universe forming complex ecological systems and evolving the human brain out of single-celled organisms by random genetic mutations" - Namely the plot for all these lives and their every interaction. Not just a bit more complex, but massivly more so.Me said:Occam's Razor