Quantcast

MRP Noken - thoughts?

Gary

my pronouns are hag/gis
Aug 27, 2002
8,751
6,712
UK
As a lighter rider, I have a hard time using most of my travel on my Zebs even with 0 tokens, especially the 160mm version. I can't run lower pressure without making it lose support, but I will end up using ~15-20mm less travel than my 160mm Lyrik on the same big g-out type compressions
May I suggest...
1732531322056.jpeg
Adding MOAR PIES!
 

Lelandjt

adorbs
Apr 4, 2008
2,656
1,011
Breckenridge, CO/Lahaina,HI
By triple I just mean the same thing as Runt / Ohlins: negative + postive 1 + positive 2. Technically conventional air springs are 2 chambers (neg / pos).
I removed the divider between the 2 positive chambers on both Marzocchi forks I had with this system. I like one big positive chamber. Then if I need to add progression it's easy to take up volume in it.
 
Feb 21, 2020
991
1,389
SoCo Western Slope
That additional "mid-stroke support" you're seeing (which if you actually look at the middle portion of travel is only a few lbs. – not even perceptible) is only coming from the stock Zeb being very progressive. You can gain even more of that type of support if you add more tokens. But at a certain point you're just giving up stroke – literally reducing your usable travel. Using tokens to gain mid-stroke support is like banging your head against the wall so you stop thinking about your tummy ache.
That's why you put a 3rd chamber like a RUNT in there; more mid support due to the decrease in volume similar to packing it full of spacers. But then reduced progression as the volume then increases once the main chamber reaches the same pressure as the RUNT and the RUNT piston starts moving.
 

ChrisRobin

Turbo Monkey
Jan 30, 2002
3,412
212
Vancouver
The Noken thing is interesting, but I agree with everyone that say "what's the point of buying an expensive fork when you have to buy upgrades right away?"

- I've tried the RUNT on a 38. It's pretty neat. It makes you feel like you have a flat tire that's how sensitive it makes it. But there's a lot of ramp up to the point where you have to deviate from the 2 to 1 psi ratio.
- I've tried the SECUS on a 40. Not bad. Didn't make a huge difference but I was warned it wouldn't do much. Overall the 40 with a SECUS and Fluid Focus valving was good.

The Ohlins forks are tricky to fine tune but once you find where you want to be, they're great. Write your settings down!
 

SkullCrack

Monkey
Sep 3, 2004
712
145
PNW
I've got one of these for sale. I used MRP's clearance test prior to buying and it looked like it was going to fit, but reality is a cruel mistress.

$50 and it's yours. It's the version for the Zeb.

FWIW I was installing it on a 2020 Specialized Enduro. Chris King DropSet 3 headset means I can't use the MRP riser crown race.
 
Last edited:

canadmos

Cake Tease
May 29, 2011
22,586
22,443
Canaderp
I've got one of these for sale. I used MRP's clearance test prior to buying and it looked like it was going to fit, but reality is a cruel mistress.

$50 and it's yours. It's the version for the Zeb.

FWIW I was installing it on a 2020 Specialized Enduro. Chris King DropSet 3 headset means I can't use the MRP riser crown race.
Would you ship to Canaderp?
 

Andeh

Customer Title
Mar 3, 2020
1,256
1,210
I've got a couple rides on mine, and it does what it says on the tin. No clearance issues on a size M Nomad 6 with a Zeb. I'm still not riding full intensity but it felt really good to me - using more travel, less ramp at the end. I am running my bike with a bit less sag currently (~15% front, 25% rear), so extrapolating if I was running a normal amount (18F/30R), I'd probably try adding 2-3 psi or more damping from a zero token setup for mid support. Still, this feels more tuneable, as even at those higher pressures, I had excellent grip over wet rocks.
 

JB450

Chimp
Apr 13, 2024
11
23
I did an experiment along the lines of a Noken.

I run a DIY Runt in my fork and wanted to negate the volume that the runt takes up. Proof of concept is pretty rough and ready, but it definitely allows more travel to be used and less ramp up.

As above the grip was better too.
Compress_20250116_165453_3836.jpg


Compress_20250116_165452_2183.jpg
 

captainspauldin

intrigued by a pole
May 14, 2007
1,318
217
Jersey Shore
That really looks like something that could be incorporated into the steerer by a good engineer.
Use the steerer itself as the body? No need to weaken the crown structure.
I was thinking the same thing. If you installed a Oneup EDC top cap / threaded steerer and re-purposed the bottom cap you could probably fit a EDC tool sized air cylinder in the steerer.
 

Jozz

Joe Dalton
Apr 18, 2002
6,836
8,875
SADL
Or maybe, maybe, just ride forks as is?

Started with a Judy SL, anything after that is glorious.
 

Jm_

sled dog's bollocks
Jan 14, 2002
20,647
11,153
AK
The fucking lengths the industry will go to so they can still not work as well as a coil spring.
 
Last edited:

JB450

Chimp
Apr 13, 2024
11
23
The fucking lengths the industry will go to so they can still not work as well as a coil spring.
I mean you are not wrong.

And the coil kit I made for this fork works really well, but I do like the way the DIY Runt I have in the air spring works/feels.

This experiment was just to see how it would behave with extra volume. Also I just love fk'ing around with suspension mods
 

toodles

ridiculously corgi proportioned
Aug 24, 2004
5,966
5,396
Australia
I still reckon a lot of the progressiveness comes from the lowers as well hey. I reckon there's only so much good extending the positive air spring volume will do before the lowers are ramping it up anyway. The Secus does something for the lowers volume doesn't it?
 

DaveW

Space Monkey
Jul 2, 2001
11,833
3,322
The bunker at parliament
I still reckon a lot of the progressiveness comes from the lowers as well hey. I reckon there's only so much good extending the positive air spring volume will do before the lowers are ramping it up anyway. The Secus does something for the lowers volume doesn't it?

Yeah it's a kind of volume expander (super simplistic take), had one on a Fox36.... made the start of the stroke mega butter smooth.... mid stroke was slightly softer and couldn't tell much difference personally when you went deep into the travel or bottomed it out due to a dumb line.
 

JB450

Chimp
Apr 13, 2024
11
23
I still reckon a lot of the progressiveness comes from the lowers as well hey. I reckon there's only so much good extending the positive air spring volume will do before the lowers are ramping it up anyway. The Secus does something for the lowers volume doesn't it?
Some progressiveness yes.

The air spring is still the most progressive part of the equation.
 

Westy

the teste
Nov 22, 2002
56,679
22,788
Sleazattle
The fucking lengths the industry will go to so they can still not work as well as a coil spring.
There are coil forks out there, they don't seem to be that popular. I also seem to remember 20 years ago a large number of threads about people doing some weird shit to their coil z1s to get more adjustability and progression out of them. Neither configuration will be ideal for everyone but the adjustability of an air spring will be better for more people.

Been along time since I had a coil fork, I remember it bottoming out too much or being harsh. Almost like you need a reasonable amount of progression like has long been determined as ideal from a rear suspension linkage.
 
Last edited:

Andeh

Customer Title
Mar 3, 2020
1,256
1,210
I put my second Zeb (this one 160) on my eeb last night, and moved the Noken over to try it there. Same experience as on my other bike, much less harshness on deep travel events but still wasn't bottoming out running the same pressure I did before. The reduced ramp let me add a click of HSC, which I prefer because it calms the fork down throughout the travel as opposed to spiking towards the bottom. Anyways, really happy with this little mod, enough that I ordered a second one so both bikes get one. The Zeb 160 air spring with a Noken feels comparable or still a little bit more supportive than a Lyrik 160, both set to the suggested pressures on the RS chart, and same damper settings.
 

Jm_

sled dog's bollocks
Jan 14, 2002
20,647
11,153
AK
There are coil forks out there, they don't seem to be that popular. I also seem to remember 20 years ago a large number of threads about people doing some weird shit to their coil z1s to get more adjustability and progression out of them. Neither configuration will be ideal for everyone but the adjustability of an air spring will be better for more people.

Been along time since I had a coil fork, I remember it bottoming out too much or being harsh. Almost like you need a reasonable amount of progression like has long been determined as ideal from a rear suspension linkage.
Well, those old forks also had fuck-all for damping too.
 

englertracing

you owe me a sandwich
Mar 5, 2012
1,697
1,196
La Verne
There are coil forks out there, they don't seem to be that popular. I also seem to remember 20 years ago a large number of threads about people doing some weird shit to their coil z1s to get more adjustability and progression out of them. Neither configuration will be ideal for everyone but the adjustability of an air spring will be better for more people.

Been along time since I had a coil fork, I remember it bottoming out too much or being harsh. Almost like you need a reasonable amount of progression like has long been determined as ideal from a rear suspension linkage.
So linkage fork :busted:
 

englertracing

you owe me a sandwich
Mar 5, 2012
1,697
1,196
La Verne
This is my opinion. I haven't checked into the MX world's air fork experiment in a while. Has air taken over for this reason or have some gone back to coil?
I think most production bikes are back to coil
Ktm still offers air.
Im not really sure what pros are racing on.

I think heat induced pressure change is a much larger problem for a mx bike
 

Gary

my pronouns are hag/gis
Aug 27, 2002
8,751
6,712
UK
people doing some weird shit to their coil z1s to get more adjustability and progression out of them.
That was also an oil bath fork. So progression and bottom out could be fine tuned pretty easily by just messing around with oil heights/volume.
 

Lelandjt

adorbs
Apr 4, 2008
2,656
1,011
Breckenridge, CO/Lahaina,HI
heat induced pressure change
This is my only problem with MTB suspension. On all of my fleet's forks & shocks I've arrived at tunes where I'm genuinely happy with the springs. Getting to that point though has made me sensitive to changes and my XC race bike might be the only one that I don't feel changing during a ride. When I'm in places with big temperature swings I have to put some effort into setting the pressures to be correct.
 

Jm_

sled dog's bollocks
Jan 14, 2002
20,647
11,153
AK
Stolen, but goddammit truthier words were never typed:

How come nobody makes a coil to air conversion? 'Cause air anything sucks.
 

Jm_

sled dog's bollocks
Jan 14, 2002
20,647
11,153
AK
I mean, they did, they were called Englund Air Cartridges. But they sucked.