keep in mind I'm a weird guy with weird taste in bikes, and may be pretty far outside the norm. I wanted tunability that I couldn't get from the RT3 menarche. I need a steep seat angle because the trails out here go up and down constantly. The BMC is also more of a long-legged trailbike than a true enduro speed bike, with a slightly too tall BB and slightly too steep HA, and that's perfect for the riding we do out here on the beast coast. I think there's plenty of reasons to like evil, but the bmc seems to be a better bike, at least right now. Keep in mind I have one ride on it and am still in the honeymoon phase, so who knows I may find some gripes with it in a few more miles.As much as EVIL(!) is the new ibis, it's funny how much better you like that BMC from the sounds of it. I don't get the evil hype.