Quantcast

Poll: Sedan or Wagon

  • Come enter the Ridemonkey Secret Santa!

    We're kicking off the 2024 Secret Santa! Exchange gifts with other monkeys - from beer and snacks, to bike gear, to custom machined holiday decorations and tools by our more talented members, there's something for everyone.

    Click here for details and to learn how to participate.

Sedan or Wagon? What's the story?

  • Sedan: More secure and better handling?

    Votes: 4 11.8%

  • Wagon: Better hauler and more useful?

    Votes: 30 88.2%
  • Total voters
    34
Barbaton

Barbaton

Turbo Monkey
May 11, 2002
1,477
0
suburban hell
So I'm in the market for a car. Yesterday I drove an Impreza. Big drawback for the sedan is that the seats don't fold down so I started thinking about the wagon.

My inclination has always been towards sedans, and have an old bias against wagons as being for old people with kids.

I have several young, ostensibly hip, outdoorsy bike/ski buddies who swear by wagons for carrying gear and insist that they're stylish and no longer fogey-mobiles. On the other hand, the GF hates wagons, and I'll never hear the end of it if I get one.

What say ye monkeys?
 
laura

laura

DH_Laura
Jul 16, 2002
6,259
15
Glitter Gulch
Wagon. Function over form my friend. I have a subaru outback wagon that i love love love. I don't think I'll own a sedan again.
 
jacksonpt

jacksonpt

Turbo Monkey
Jul 22, 2002
6,791
59
Vestal, NY
I drove an impreza last week as well and I'd only consider the wagon. The old big, wood-paneled wagons were for old people... now adays they make sport wagons which are don't have that same stereotype. Go with a smaller sportier wagon... IMO, the added function FAAAAR outweighs what might be a slightly less appealing (aesthetically) car.
 
S

skinny mike

Turbo Monkey
Jan 24, 2005
6,415
0
as soccer-momish as it is, i would love to have my moms volvo xc70 because it can haul a ton of stuff inside and its quite comfortable. the handling is pretty good too for its size. but with the impreza i would most certainly spring for the wagon, they are quite sexy.
 
Barbaton

Barbaton

Turbo Monkey
May 11, 2002
1,477
0
suburban hell
One of the things I didn't like about the wagon was that the cargo space, without the seats down, is really small, compared to the surprisingly large trunk on the sedan. Just to throw that in the mix.
 
bikenweed

bikenweed

Turbo Monkey
Oct 21, 2004
2,432
0
Los Osos
It's a lot easier to bone curbhucker's friend's mom in a wagon, there's more space. If you need any more clarification don't hesitate to ask.
 
L

Lex

Monkey
Dec 6, 2001
594
0
Massachusetts
Definitely a wagon. I'm on my second VW Jetta 1.8T wagon and I love my car. With the turbo it's a lot of fun to drive and I have tons of room for everything. Great traveling car.
 
jacksonpt

jacksonpt

Turbo Monkey
Jul 22, 2002
6,791
59
Vestal, NY
I'm curious why, in your poll, you said that a sedan was more secure and better handling. Most wagons come with those cargo cover things if you're worried about people seeing your gear. If someone is going to break a window to get in, then they're going to do it to a wagon or a sedan. And perhaps if you're an indy car driver the sedan is better handling... I'd be surprised if the average joe would see any difference.
 
Nick

Nick

My name is Nick
Sep 21, 2001
24,907
16,478
where the trails are
I have a A4 sedan, and with the rear seats folded down I have ample room for fun stuff.
The bike fits fine, though it requires removing one or both wheels (depends on which bike I have).
If I was shopping for a new car today, I'd definitely consider a wagon.
 
N8 v2.0

N8 v2.0

Not the sharpest tool in the shed
Oct 18, 2002
11,003
149
The Cleft of Venus
jacksonpt said:
I'm curious why, in your poll, you said that a sedan was more secure and better handling. Most wagons come with those cargo cover things if you're worried about people seeing your gear. If someone is going to break a window to get in, then they're going to do it to a wagon or a sedan. And perhaps if you're an indy car driver the sedan is better handling... I'd be surprised if the average joe would see any difference.
Click to expand...
A friend of mine was TDY here last week and he had a Dodge wagon (not sure of the name) and it was roomy and handeled well.
 
DNA

DNA

The human raccoon
Jan 31, 2003
1,443
0
NH
I have had wagons for the last 10 years and wouldn't go back now. I am picking up a new Matrix today (and all of the other cars I considered were wagons too),
 
syadasti

syadasti

i heart mac
Apr 15, 2002
12,690
290
VT
In many case vehicles that are available in sedan and wagon form, the wagon has better weight distribution but isn't as rigid of a structure as a sedan.

I test drove the new 2007 VW passat wagon about a week ago with the 2L Turbo - seemed like a great deal. Most dealers are selling them at invoice right now - the salesman showed/offered me it and I didn't ask for pricing information...

 
valve bouncer

valve bouncer

Master Dildoist
Feb 11, 2002
7,843
114
Japan
gnurider1080 said:
as soccer-momish as it is, i would love to have my moms volvo xc70 because it can haul a ton of stuff inside and its quite comfortable.
Click to expand...
Don't let Partsbara hear you call the XC70 soccer momish. Have to admit too that it didn't feel too soccer mum like on the autobahn at 190K+. Would have gone faster too but for the governor.
 
Toshi

Toshi

butthole powerwashing evangelist
Oct 23, 2001
39,750
8,748
sedan + ski pass through + sportworks hitch rack FTW
 
peter6061

peter6061

Turbo Monkey
Nov 19, 2001
1,575
0
Kenmore, WA
Going through this same debate right now with my wife. i like the looks of the sedan better than the wagon. Currently I own an impreza wagon and love it, but most trips we've taken could have easily been done in a sedan. Even with the seats down, the large amount of gear we take doesn't usually rise above the windows. Bikes / Boats go on the roof.

Granted, the Outback 2.5 XT is looking pretty good for us at this time as well, and would hold more if I need to transport more than two people.

So for you, I'm going to have to say wagon.
 
DNA

DNA

The human raccoon
Jan 31, 2003
1,443
0
NH
-BB- said:
Don't like the Wagon image?
Get a darn SUV then. All the benefits fo the wagon with more clearance.
Click to expand...
Plus crappier gas mileage!

Edit: Not that I am a hippy or anything, I am just cheap.
 
jvp108

jvp108

king of the road
Mar 21, 2006
153
0
filthadelphia
I have a 2002 WRX, and I will tell you that I don't like my subaru. Lots of manufacturing problems. QC stuff, not wear and tear.
 
robdamanii

robdamanii

OMG! <3 Tom Brady!
May 2, 2005
10,677
0
Out of my mind, back in a moment.
jvp108 said:
I have a 2002 WRX, and I will tell you that I don't like my subaru. Lots of manufacturing problems. QC stuff, not wear and tear.
Click to expand...
Yeah, like you said in the other thread.

Funny, I know half a dozen WRX owners, and none of them had the same problems. Perhaps you got a lemon?
 
jvp108

jvp108

king of the road
Mar 21, 2006
153
0
filthadelphia
robdamanii said:
Yeah, like you said in the other thread.

Funny, I know half a dozen WRX owners, and none of them had the same problems. Perhaps you got a lemon?
Click to expand...
Lemon, maybe. The clutch was a manufacturing defect that affected many many drivers. So much so that it was documented with a Technical Service Bulletin. Same thing with the radiator and fuel leak.

No car is perfect, esp. first model runs (although it was only new to US shores, the rest of the world had the WRX far longer)

Just thought I'd post my 2 cents, not telling anyone to buy or not to buy. I've heard that Subarus are fairly bulletproof, on average.
 
Barbaton

Barbaton

Turbo Monkey
May 11, 2002
1,477
0
suburban hell
stoney98 said:
I can fit my 4x w/ wheels off in the cargo area with seats up.
Get a hitch and a sportwerks 2 bike rack.
Click to expand...
I have a roof rack that I'll be swapping over, so it's not a question so much about putting bikes in the car.

I'm impressed that the response here is pretty one sided. I didn't know y'all were such wagon fiends. :cool:
 
Toshi

Toshi

butthole powerwashing evangelist
Oct 23, 2001
39,750
8,748
jvp108 said:
Lemon, maybe. The clutch was a manufacturing defect that affected many many drivers. So much so that it was documented with a Technical Service Bulletin. Same thing with the radiator and fuel leak.
Click to expand...
i don't know about the radiator, but i can confirm that the cold weather fuel smell/leak and clutch chatter were both real issues. subaru ended up fixing both (by replacing fuel lines and the clutch) for owners who came in and complained.
 
vamkie

vamkie

Chimp
Mar 8, 2006
29
0
i will never own anything other than a Grand Cherokee. my 97 has been pretty much the perfect vehicle for me.
 
stevew

stevew

resident influencer
Sep 21, 2001
41,159
10,097
syadasti said:
I test drove the new 2007 VW passat wagon about a week ago with the 2L Turbo -

Click to expand...
For some reason I didn't think we would be seeing these in the states until later in the year......

Those front ends.....ehh.

I'm partial to wagons since I have one. I like the Subaru Legacy Wagons over their other ones.
 
laura

laura

DH_Laura
Jul 16, 2002
6,259
15
Glitter Gulch
robdamanii said:
Yeah, like you said in the other thread.

Funny, I know half a dozen WRX owners, and none of them had the same problems. Perhaps you got a lemon?
Click to expand...

I got an outback lemon. took several months and a lemon law suit to get the problem fixed. Subaru seems to have issues with lemons.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom