Quantcast

The next Shimano gravity group? opinions?

hitar_potar

Monkey
Sep 23, 2011
173
6
Ruse, Bulgaria
Soo, i find it odd there is not a single word in the web regarding the future of Zee and more to the point, Saint. Aren't they due for an upgrade in 2017? We all know how Sram is gonna play from now on - the masterpiece 7-speed for Dh and the new 12-speed for everything else. Shimano can't yet keep up with the 11 speeds cause of a too late start. But they were first in the speciffic DH-group wagon and the Saint is a notorious gravity model.
Not sure how many years the first gen had, but the second one was a 2009 model, the third one was a 2013. So, this means we are in for some news in 2017 (or probably even during 2016), right? Opinions on what the fourth gen will feature, any rumors, heads-ups??? What do you guys think? :)
 

thad

Monkey
Sep 28, 2004
388
21
My guesses:

That new freehub design that is kinda like DT or King ringdrive, except coasts with less drag

Cranks will get a lil lighter and use that steel plated carbon chainring
 

hitar_potar

Monkey
Sep 23, 2011
173
6
Ruse, Bulgaria
Yeah, but what about brakes? What can they do to make them even better than they already are? Would we finally see a Freeza 6-bolt rotor? Cause Superstar Components already makes one, although it's not an exact copy. And the gears - would they go the Sram route with 7 speeds, any cogs smaller than 11t, lighter materials but yet strong enough? And would they finally accept that their hubs have to get sealed bearings in order to cope better with gravity tasks? :)
 

kidwoo

Artisanal Tweet Curator
Yeah, but what about brakes? What can they do to make them even better than they already are?
Make them stop leaking brake fluid all over my brake pads any time my bike sits for 3 days.

Come up with a system that doesn't harbor so many little air bubbles that tilting a bike in one of several ways doesn't change the engagement point, sometimes so badly there's literally no braking force until pumped up.

You know......the "little things".
 

iRider

Turbo Monkey
Apr 5, 2008
5,686
3,143
Make them stop leaking brake fluid all over my brake pads any time my bike sits for 3 days.

Come up with a system that doesn't harbor so many little air bubbles that tilting a bike in one of several ways doesn't change the engagement point, sometimes so badly there's literally no braking force until pumped up.

You know......the "little things".
You are not talking about Avid brakes, are you? ;)
 

maxyedor

<b>TOOL PRO</b>
Oct 20, 2005
5,496
3,141
In the bathroom, fighting a battle
Saint Di2, 11spd or midget 7 speed cassette, and a mechanical 11spd Saint mech and shifter roughly between XT and XTR.

Hubs will remain the same, but I could see a carbon wrapped rim like the XTR wheels have.

Brakes, I'll second Mr. Woo, hopefully they get the reliability dialed in, maybe shave a couple grams and add more wacky shit to the rotors. Or, bring back the twin rotor brakes!
 

wydopen

Turbo Monkey
Jan 16, 2005
1,229
60
805
Make them stop leaking brake fluid all over my brake pads any time my bike sits for 3 days.

Come up with a system that doesn't harbor so many little air bubbles that tilting a bike in one of several ways doesn't change the engagement point, sometimes so badly there's literally no braking force until pumped up.

You know......the "little things".
some modulation would be nice too...they might as well just have an on/off button..might save some weight...maybe they just work better on the internet than they do on the trail...
 

ritche

Monkey
Dec 3, 2011
311
19
feasible:

1. electronic shifting with push buttons.
2. brake, technology as is, but 220 mm optimized rotor diameter as standard for 650B dh bikes
3 . DH specific 7 speed casette from shimano.
4. Carbonz on crank arms, BB body, Hub body, floating rotor body, break levers, cassette spider, rims,

maybe:
1. Belt driven internal geared (7) speed hub for DH. (exisitng = alfine but heavy).
 

HAB

Chelsea from Seattle
Apr 28, 2007
11,589
2,021
Seattle
feasible:

1. electronic shifting with push buttons.
2. brake, technology as is, but 220 mm optimized rotor diameter as standard for 650B dh bikes
3 . DH specific 7 speed casette from shimano.
4. Carbonz on crank arms, BB body, Hub body, floating rotor body, break levers, cassette spider, rims,

maybe:
1. Belt driven internal geared (7) speed hub for DH. (exisitng = alfine but heavy).
Not a chance Saint gets carbon cranks etc before XTR.
 

kickstand

Turbo Monkey
Sep 18, 2009
3,441
393
Fenton, MI
Yeah, but what about brakes? What can they do to make them even better than they already are? Would we finally see a Freeza 6-bolt rotor? Cause Superstar Components already makes one, although it's not an exact copy. And the gears - would they go the Sram route with 7 speeds, any cogs smaller than 11t, lighter materials but yet strong enough? And would they finally accept that their hubs have to get sealed bearings in order to cope better with gravity tasks? :)
They could make the brakes stop sucking, that would make them better.
 

kidwoo

Artisanal Tweet Curator
some modulation would be nice too...they might as well just have an on/off button..might save some weight...maybe they just work better on the internet than they do on the trail...
I don't have a problem with the modulation. Like anything else, you just get used to it. I've got no problem braking a lot or a little and changing through an 'event'

I got a lot of cheap brakes from friends that bought some and killed themselves in the first week of riding them.

"these things are gnarly, you want them?" :rofl:
 

HAB

Chelsea from Seattle
Apr 28, 2007
11,589
2,021
Seattle
I don't have a problem with the modulation. Like anything else, you just get used to it. I've got no problem braking a lot or a little and changing through an 'event'
Yeah joking aside, I'm with you on the modulation. I've actually managed to get both pairs of my XTRs pretty solid, but my Saints have always been a little funky.
 

hitar_potar

Monkey
Sep 23, 2011
173
6
Ruse, Bulgaria
Ummm, why would you need a Di2 version of the Saint? Would it be so much better than a regular one? Or is it only for the bling? And why would you need an 11-speed version? Sram showed us 7-speed is enough, given that the gears are selected wisely. As far as carbon crank, i think they'll stay alu - they don't look ready to shake things up seriously.
Last time when 820 group was about to be revealed, we saw photos of Gwin riding and testing different prototypes of the drivetrain - derailleurs, brakes, shifter etc. Then i thing Gee Atherton had a go on some prototypes (around the time we saw him on the USD Fox fork). So, we had some sort of an idea as to what's coming. But now... nothing. :(
 

blackohio

Generous jaywalker
Mar 12, 2009
2,773
122
Hellafornia. Formerly stumptown.
Ummm, why would you need a Di2 version of the Saint? Would it be so much better than a regular one? Or is it only for the bling? And why would you need an 11-speed version? Sram showed us 7-speed is enough, given that the gears are selected wisely. As far as carbon crank, i think they'll stay alu - they don't look ready to shake things up seriously.
Last time when 820 group was about to be revealed, we saw photos of Gwin riding and testing different prototypes of the drivetrain - derailleurs, brakes, shifter etc. Then i thing Gee Atherton had a go on some prototypes (around the time we saw him on the USD Fox fork). So, we had some sort of an idea as to what's coming. But now... nothing. :(
Have you ever played with / set-up di2? its pretty fucking awesome. Unfortunately 1X looses much of its awesomeness, having a derailleur that can micro adjust or never loose adjustment over time is pretty cool.

Shimano testing products is no real indication to timed releases. shimano releases on a schedule. XT last year, Dura-Ace this year, saint/zee next year. They have a mapped out table they follow. While whats part of that mapped table can change depending on market direction. Shimano also tests for much longer prior to releasing so to minimize revisions. SRAM and Shimano have wildly different production schedules. SRAM I believe manufacture a set product group throughout the year. Shimano forecasts and builds to forecasts one time a year for given products. This can be a challenge if theres a unexpected jump in demand, however it allows shimano to spend more time from prototype to production working on said products, since it's release might not be for 2 years from prototype phase. This has its own unique set of challenges, but Yozo says shimano is a design/engineering and manufacturing company long before a bike component manufacturer.
 

slimshady

¡Mira, una ardilla!
I believe Shimano will release a SLX 1x11-centric gruppo this year, the middle pack OEM trail bike market is where SRAM is killing Shimano, even more since NX was released last week, and with the upcoming X01 Eagle 1x12 being released in one month, the Raising Sun boys will have to show something appealing pretty soon.
 

Dogboy

Turbo Monkey
Apr 12, 2004
3,215
618
Durham, NC
I believe Shimano will release a SLX 1x11-centric gruppo this year, the middle pack OEM trail bike market is where SRAM is killing Shimano, even more since NX was released last week, and with the upcoming X01 Eagle 1x12 being released in one month, the Raising Sun boys will have to show something appealing pretty soon.
I think so too. I've seen upcoming bikes spec'd with unnamed Shimano components in the SLX price range.
 

HAB

Chelsea from Seattle
Apr 28, 2007
11,589
2,021
Seattle
Have you ever played with / set-up di2? its pretty fucking awesome. Unfortunately 1X looses much of its awesomeness, having a derailleur that can micro adjust or never loose adjustment over time is pretty cool.
Yeah. I have it on my (gasp!) road bike, and really, really like it there. I'm less enthused about it on a 1x mountain setup because a lot of the advantages have to do with the better management of the front derailleur, and because the rear derailleurs are expensive. Fine on a road bike, but scary on a mountain bike where the possibility of smashing shit is higher. That said if I was made of money I'd absolutely run XTR Di2 because it does work great.
 

maxyedor

<b>TOOL PRO</b>
Oct 20, 2005
5,496
3,141
In the bathroom, fighting a battle
Ummm, why would you need a Di2 version of the Saint? Would it be so much better than a regular one? Or is it only for the bling? And why would you need an 11-speed version? Sram showed us 7-speed is enough, given that the gears are selected wisely. As far as carbon crank, i think they'll stay alu - they don't look ready to shake things up seriously.
11 speed makes sense for commonality, it means they're no longer putting money into top tier 10spd driveline parts. It also means the top groups can share things like shifters and cassettes with their non-gravity line-up, like Saint/Zee always have.

The 11/7 speed thing is rider preference. Not everybody wants a dedicated DH bike, and Shimano would like to sell those people and OEMs Saint and Zee, so having Saint 11spd parts makes sense, even if they're just rebadged XT or XTR.

Di2 is just awesome. Seriously, try it, it shifts so smooth. Seeing as most people aren't riding their DH bike every day, they can easily charge the thing during the week, while cleaning/prepping for the weekend. Perfect application of e-shifting IMHO. They could even incorporated a "normal button" to quickly get you back to your 1 prefered gear after a sprint or climb with no need to click through 4-5 gears one at a time.

Carbon crank simply isn't happening, you'll see that in their Road groups first.
 

Jm_

sled dog's bollocks
Jan 14, 2002
20,065
10,630
AK
M801HD "re-generator brakes" w/stator caliper
M802HD electric drive BB
M803HD seat tube battery

Done.
 

HAB

Chelsea from Seattle
Apr 28, 2007
11,589
2,021
Seattle
Di2 is just awesome. Seriously, try it, it shifts so smooth. Seeing as most people aren't riding their DH bike every day, they can easily charge the thing during the week, while cleaning/prepping for the weekend.
I'm blown away with how long the battery lasts. I don't really pay much attention to mileage on my road bike because who cares, but I get a couple months out of a charge, riding at least once a week on average.
 

HAB

Chelsea from Seattle
Apr 28, 2007
11,589
2,021
Seattle
Ha ha... 8 WHOLE rides?
Ha. Definitely way more than that, my guestimation was a bit crap.


Maybe it's not really that impressive, but relative to smartphones and laptops and shit it feels pretty good.
 

HAB

Chelsea from Seattle
Apr 28, 2007
11,589
2,021
Seattle
I'd also add that I definitely don't think it's night and day better than cables or anything. It works. So do "normal" derailleurs. It was at most a minor consideration when I bought the bike, and would be a minor consideration for my next one too. I just found a deal on a bike I liked that happened to have it.
 

manhattanprjkt83

Rusty Trombone
Jul 10, 2003
9,660
1,237
Nilbog
I've probably already said too much but I like the idea of wireless electronics. We as a forum have a bad tendency towards hating progress but wireless mechs make a ton of sense. The XTR di2 stuff is really good, it's still expensive but quite a few of us will be riding it when it comes down. That said, I don't want anything to do with wires and I doubt any of this will debut with a DH groupo.
 

manhattanprjkt83

Rusty Trombone
Jul 10, 2003
9,660
1,237
Nilbog
I'm blown away with how long the battery lasts. I don't really pay much attention to mileage on my road bike because who cares, but I get a couple months out of a charge, riding at least once a week on average.
Agree'd I don't mind charging my bike once a month or gasp twice. I charge my lights 3 times a week for rides this time of year...
 

Gary

my pronouns are hag/gis
Aug 27, 2002
8,493
6,380
UK
We as a forum have a bad tendency towards hating progress but wireless mechs make a ton of sense.
No. No. They may make a ton of sense to you. And that's great! I wish you all the best with your acceptance of all perceived progress. where will this all end though?
GPS assisted Carbon E-bikes with integrated Di3 wireless gearing and heated seats/grips? Bluetooth ABS braking? Accelerometer, gyro, proximity sensors? Automatic Gnar/steep sensing wireless dropper posts? telemetry controlled electronically adjusted and damped suspension? 4"+ tyres? automatic lighting? Matching fanny packs/luggage?

Why wait for 2017 Shimano?

The future is now...

 

manhattanprjkt83

Rusty Trombone
Jul 10, 2003
9,660
1,237
Nilbog
No. No. They may make a ton of sense to you. And that's great! I wish you all the best with your acceptance of all perceived progress. where will this all end though?
GPS assisted Carbon E-bikes with integrated Di3 wireless gearing and heated seats/grips? Bluetooth ABS braking? Accelerometer, gyro, proximity sensors? Automatic Gnar/steep sensing wireless dropper posts? telemetry controlled electronically adjusted and damped suspension? 4"+ tyres? automatic lighting? Matching fanny packs/luggage?

Why wait for 2017 Shimano?

The future is now...


Whoa, someone's thumb shifter must have failed mid ride tonight. Holy hell.