Quantcast

what's the ACLU's problem with the cross?

$tinkle

Expert on blowing
Feb 12, 2003
14,591
6
from silver's backyard:
ACLU Demands Removal Of Cross From LA County Seal

LOS ANGELES (city of angels!) -- The American Civil Liberties Union is demanding the removal of a tiny cross that is among historic symbols on Los Angeles County's official seal.


The seal "prominently depicts a Latin cross, a sectarian religious symbol that represents the beliefs of one segment of the county's diverse population" and is an "impermissible endorsement of Christianity" by the county government, the ACLU Foundation of Southern California said in a letter to county officials this week.

the rest
i'm trying to understand what their beef is with the cross. Is it really that offensive? Do/have they also fight/fought against more offensive material: kiddie porn, vulgarity, obese SUV drivers, halitosis?
 

Andyman_1970

Turbo Monkey
Apr 4, 2003
3,105
5
The Natural State
It's not like some dude or dudete that is employed by the state is on the street corner screaming in people faces "SINNER, NOW IS THE TIME TO COME COME TO JESUS!!!!"

Anyway, are those same ACLU folks offended by the Jewish star of David, or the Muslim Cresent.........on and on and on.
 

$tinkle

Expert on blowing
Feb 12, 2003
14,591
6
Originally posted by Andyman_1970
It's not like some dude or dudete that is employed by the state is on the street corner screaming in people faces "SINNER, NOW IS THE TIME TO COME COME TO JESUS!!!!"
but this is to prevent that very situation from unfolding - consider this pre-emption.

i also saw a blurb how they're railing against miami-dade cops for this wknd's outdoor thug-fest, cuz there's too many, which could indicate racial profiling. So it seems they care more about hurting some revelers' feelings than presenting a strong police presence to keep folks in line so they won't take a leak on some storefront, litter to excess, brawl, and other anonymous behaviour that comes from massive crowds.

i don't so much want them to burn in hell as i do in front of me. And i want them to defend my right to watch it.
 

LordOpie

MOTHER HEN
Oct 17, 2002
21,022
3
Denver
Originally posted by Andyman_1970
Anyway, are those same ACLU folks offended by the Jewish star of David, or the Muslim Cresent.........on and on and on.
they should allow all popular religious symbols.
 

Silver

find me a tampon
Jul 20, 2002
10,840
1
Orange County, CA
Originally posted by Andyman_1970
It's not like some dude or dudete that is employed by the state is on the street corner screaming in people faces "SINNER, NOW IS THE TIME TO COME COME TO JESUS!!!!"

Anyway, are those same ACLU folks offended by the Jewish star of David, or the Muslim Cresent.........on and on and on.
I for one want "In God we Trust" on our money replaced with "L. Ron Hubbard was right!"
 

$tinkle

Expert on blowing
Feb 12, 2003
14,591
6
Originally posted by Silver
I for one want "In God we Trust" on our money replaced with "L. Ron Hubbard was right!"
or the cheap version: Neo-Tech.

isn't it funny no-one from the hollywood inner circle makes fun of travolta, cruise, that chic on JAG, etc. for their beliefs?
 

Andyman_1970

Turbo Monkey
Apr 4, 2003
3,105
5
The Natural State
Originally posted by $tinkle
isn't it funny no-one from the hollywood inner circle makes fun of travolta, cruise, that chic on JAG, etc. for their beliefs?
Could it be because they have a "milk toast" faith with little conviction or commitment?

I don't know as I'm not totally familiar with the whole Scientology deal (so I could be wrong).
 

Silver

find me a tampon
Jul 20, 2002
10,840
1
Orange County, CA
Originally posted by $tinkle
or the cheap version: Neo-Tech.

isn't it funny no-one from the hollywood inner circle makes fun of travolta, cruise, that chic on JAG, etc. for their beliefs?
That's because they make money for them.

That doesn't mean that they aren't fvcking nutballs. The chick from Everybody loves Raymond is a scientologist as well, I think.
 

$tinkle

Expert on blowing
Feb 12, 2003
14,591
6
Originally posted by LordOpie
they should allow all popular religious symbols.
who is "they"? i assume you mean the aclu, but they have no governance, ya? :confused:

if you think they should, would that also allow for depictions as, say - to be totally random - a mosque with a warning sign out front?
 

BuddhaRoadkill

I suck at Tool
Feb 15, 2004
988
0
Chintimini Bog
Thank God for the ACLU!!! ;)

Seriously though, no religious symbol or reference should be anywhere near a government institution. To do so wipes away several hundred years of progress and brings us back to the Divine Right of Kings. The seal of LA is not the seal of God and they should not advertise it as such. The beauty of our system is that [in theory] it's a government for the people, by the people - not by God or any other god.
 

$tinkle

Expert on blowing
Feb 12, 2003
14,591
6
Originally posted by BuddhaRoadkill
Thank God for the ACLU!!! ;)

Seriously though, no religious symbol or reference should be anywhere near a government institution. To do so wipes away several hundred years of progress and brings us back to the Divine Right of Kings. The seal of LA is not the seal of God and they should not advertise it as such. The beauty of our system is that [in theory] it's a government for the people, by the people - not by God or any other god.
the problem here isn't that the seal is a cross, but that a cross is part of the seal. What happened to the government acknowledging diversity of beliefs, to include no beliefs? If the folks who came up with the seal were elected officials - a reasonable conclusion - would they not have done the will of the people? If there is such a clamor for secularism, why not have that as one of the platform items for the next batch of candidates? methinks the aclu needs to find true violations of civil liberties.
 

Serial Midget

Al Bundy
Jun 25, 2002
13,053
1,897
Fort of Rio Grande
I agree - no religious symbols should be connected with govornment institutions - it should not be on the currency either. In God We Trust my ass - it's money that I want.

Originally posted by BuddhaRoadkill
Thank God for the ACLU!!! ;)

Seriously though, no religious symbol or reference should be anywhere near a government institution. To do so wipes away several hundred years of progress and brings us back to the Divine Right of Kings. The seal of LA is not the seal of God and they should not advertise it as such. The beauty of our system is that [in theory] it's a government for the people, by the people - not by God or any other god.
 

LordOpie

MOTHER HEN
Oct 17, 2002
21,022
3
Denver
Originally posted by zod
Like Pentagrams???? :devil:
I don't think many people worship the devil, but I'm thinking Wiccans need better representation. They have sex with trees, right?
 

Silver

find me a tampon
Jul 20, 2002
10,840
1
Orange County, CA
Originally posted by $tinkle
the problem here isn't that the seal is a cross, but that a cross is part of the seal. What happened to the government acknowledging diversity of beliefs, to include no beliefs? If the folks who came up with the seal were elected officials - a reasonable conclusion - would they not have done the will of the people? If there is such a clamor for secularism, why not have that as one of the platform items for the next batch of candidates? methinks the aclu needs to find true violations of civil liberties.
I'm going to be really disappointed in you when Scientologists end up with political control of a town or county and you start screaming foul...

Having said that, I think this one may be a mountain out of a molehill. It would be easier for everyone involved if you quietly went to them and said, hey, your seal isn't really constitutional...you might want to think about a redesign.
 

LordOpie

MOTHER HEN
Oct 17, 2002
21,022
3
Denver
Originally posted by $tinkle
the problem here isn't that the seal is a cross, but that a cross is part of the seal. What happened to the government acknowledging diversity of beliefs, to include no beliefs? If the folks who came up with the seal were elected officials - a reasonable conclusion - would they not have done the will of the people? If there is such a clamor for secularism, why not have that as one of the platform items for the next batch of candidates? methinks the aclu needs to find true violations of civil liberties.
I'm in agreeance, sort of.

Same with currency and "In G-d..."

Thing is, all *new* seals, legislation, whatever need to be conscious of this stuff, but I see no reason to change anything in existence unless it encourages hate... like the rebel flag.

A cross on a seal really hurts no one.
 

Tenchiro

Attention K Mart Shoppers
Jul 19, 2002
5,407
0
New England
I remember when I was young and impressionable and first moved to Portland. I was walking by the Scientologist building and was talked into a "free personality test". Well after wasting like 45 minutes taking the thing and having it analyzed, they proceeded to tell me that I was quite possibly the worst person i the world. The only way to fix myself was of course to pay them lots of money for classes. :rolleyes:

I have read that they actually think these problems are caused by a galactic overlord named Xenu. Who is currently trapped in some volcano somewhere.
 

Serial Midget

Al Bundy
Jun 25, 2002
13,053
1,897
Fort of Rio Grande
I can see were some people might see the cross as a symbol of intolerence and oppression - the religious just can't imagine that their ideals and actions would be offensive to anyone, after all - they are just trying to save our souls.
 

Skookum

bikey's is cool
Jul 26, 2002
10,184
0
in a bear cave
Originally posted by Serial Midget
I can see were some people might see the cross as a symbol of intolerence and oppression - the religious just can't imagine that their ideals and actions would be offensive to anyone, after all - they are just trying to save our souls.
and eradicate the native population in the name of god..... oh but that was so 150 years ago..... moving on.....
 

LordOpie

MOTHER HEN
Oct 17, 2002
21,022
3
Denver
Originally posted by Skookum
and eradicate the native population in the name of god..... oh but that was so 150 years ago..... moving on.....
don't you have a bingo game to get to?

{double evil score for slamming his heritage -and- his age}

:D
 

BurlyShirley

Rex Grossman Will Rise Again
Jul 4, 2002
19,180
17
TN
Originally posted by Tenchiro
I remember when I was young and impressionable and first moved to Portland. I was walking by the Scientologist building and was talked into a "free personality test". Well after wasting like 45 minutes taking the thing and having it analyzed, they proceeded to tell me that I was quite possibly the worst person i the world. The only way to fix myself was of course to pay them lots of money for classes. :rolleyes:

I have read that they actually think these problems are caused by a galactic overlord named Xenu. Who is currently trapped in some volcano somewhere.

are you ****ing serious? I know nothing of scientology, honestly, but I always see those dudes hanging outside their "temple" here. Always wondered what was up.


Xenu? You have to be ****ing kidding, right?
 

BurlyShirley

Rex Grossman Will Rise Again
Jul 4, 2002
19,180
17
TN
Originally posted by BurlySurly
are you ****ing serious? I know nothing of scientology, honestly, but I always see those dudes hanging outside their "temple" here. Always wondered what was up.


Xenu? You have to be ****ing kidding, right?
Holy crap...you are serious. Just googled it. WTF is wrong with people?







.........well i guess its no more unbelievable than jesus or something, but "xenu" that just begs to be fake.
 

ito

Mr. Schwinn Effing Armstrong
Oct 3, 2003
1,709
0
Avoiding the nine to five
Originally posted by BuddhaRoadkill
Thank God for the ACLU!!! ;)

Seriously though, no religious symbol or reference should be anywhere near a government institution. To do so wipes away several hundred years of progress and brings us back to the Divine Right of Kings. The seal of LA is not the seal of God and they should not advertise it as such. The beauty of our system is that [in theory] it's a government for the people, by the people - not by God or any other god.


I suppose they should stop teaching grade schoolers about the missionaries that "founded" California too. The symbol of the cross is part of California's history. The missions built up and down the coast have meaning for many of the people in this state. Sure, we can deny that these buildings existed, condemn them to destruction(we wouldn't want the state protecting a religious/historical site, right?), but what good is denying a large part of our history?

The missionaries did some nasty things to the natives, but then again so did pretty much everyone. Regardless, the missionaries paved the road for California to be populated and taken over by settlers. You can't exactly claim that this is a bad thing.

Damn! I just realized, most major cities in California are named after Catholic Saints.....jesus H. Christ! We need to abolish them too, can't be giving anyone ideas :rolleyes:

The Ito