Quantcast

♠°♠ mondGMT ♠•♠

Sandwich

Pig my fish!
Staff member
May 23, 2002
21,088
6,024
borcester rhymes
I will say my Camp Chef is amazing. Great temp range, it's wide so full ribs fit and has done a verity of crap very well so far.

Propane 24"
interesting. I've considered propane in the past, because having propane smoked ribs is better than not having BBQ ribs at all, and being able to just flip the switch, throw some chips in there, then do the thing is really appealing.

I was going to go for a Weber Smokey mountain vertical water smoker, but those are super expensive and never go on sale, and the dilemma of building and maintaining a fire for 12 hours just fucking blows.

My Dad bought me a Traeger. I've had some issues getting settings right, because I'm not a bbq specialist, but their customer support is incredible. Works pretty damn well though.
I've heard those are the most difficult (side firebox). The vertical waters are more forgiving for joeys like me but still give great results...
 

stoney

Part of the unwashed, middle-American horde
Jul 26, 2006
21,647
7,324
Colorado
I've heard those are the most difficult (side firebox). The vertical waters are more forgiving for joeys like me but still give great results...
The issue we've had the biggest issue with is not having enough pellets (oops) and the tstat not always working right. Turns out having it in the sun is not the best placement.
 

jimmydean

The Official Meat of Ridemonkey
Sep 10, 2001
41,266
13,383
Portland, OR
interesting. I've considered propane in the past, because having propane smoked ribs is better than not having BBQ ribs at all, and being able to just flip the switch, throw some chips in there, then do the thing is really appealing.

I was going to go for a Weber Smokey mountain vertical water smoker, but those are super expensive and never go on sale, and the dilemma of building and maintaining a fire for 12 hours just fucking blows.



I've heard those are the most difficult (side firebox). The vertical waters are more forgiving for joeys like me but still give great results...
I have not used it for anything above 225 yet, but it gets to at least 325 so it does more than just smoke meat.

With the Webber iGrill, it is now almost too easy. I set a temp range, put in pellets, and replenish every 40 min or so for about 3-4 trays, then just let it go until done. Smoking for 1/3 to 1/2 total time seems best. I have 4 different flavors of pellets depending on what I am smoking.
 

jonKranked

Detective Dookie
Nov 10, 2005
86,058
24,587
media blackout
I have not used it for anything above 225 yet, but it gets to at least 325 so it does more than just smoke meat.

With the Webber iGrill, it is now almost too easy. I set a temp range, put in pellets, and replenish every 40 min or so for about 3-4 trays, then just let it go until done. Smoking for 1/3 to 1/2 total time seems best. I have 4 different flavors of pellets depending on what I am smoking.
tell me about the igrill thingy. we got a genesis II (propane) in the spring and is compatible with it.
 

Yossarian

Monkey Pimp
Jul 25, 2001
1,702
99
Aboard the Inchcliffe Castle
Hello all. Had a busy weekend. Most of Saturday was spent at the Georgia games, where my son threw a PR and took first place in the 15-16 YO Discus. Iron Maiden later that evening and cooking all day on sunday. Now I am bored at work and thinking about my beach trip next week.
 

jimmydean

The Official Meat of Ridemonkey
Sep 10, 2001
41,266
13,383
Portland, OR
tell me about the igrill thingy. we got a genesis II (propane) in the spring and is compatible with it.
I bought the iGrill 2 with 3 meat probes and an ambient temperature probe. It was designed for a Webber grill, so it is a 2 piece system with the battery pack separate.

I made a bracket to hold the monitor and mounted it to the optional shelf. The pack is velcro'ed to the underside of said shelf.

It's Bluetooth so range is limited, but I can monitor from the living room, so that works.

Lots of meat presets, timer, and self settings. Other than sometimes not reconnecting once back in range, it's pretty awesome. On Android I sometimes have to restart the app to connect, but it seems to recall what we were doing before, so it will resume.
 

jonKranked

Detective Dookie
Nov 10, 2005
86,058
24,587
media blackout
I bought the iGrill 2 with 3 meat probes and an ambient temperature probe. It was designed for a Webber grill, so it is a 2 piece system with the battery pack separate.

I made a bracket to hold the monitor and mounted it to the optional shelf. The pack is velcro'ed to the underside of said shelf.

It's Bluetooth so range is limited, but I can monitor from the living room, so that works.

Lots of meat presets, timer, and self settings. Other than sometimes not reconnecting once back in range, it's pretty awesome. On Android I sometimes have to restart the app to connect, but it seems to recall what we were doing before, so it will resume.
does it actually control anything or is it just a fancy wireless meat thermometer?
 

jimmydean

The Official Meat of Ridemonkey
Sep 10, 2001
41,266
13,383
Portland, OR
does it actually control anything or is it just a fancy wireless meat thermometer?
Fancy wireless meat thermometer. I think I spent $70 including the Camp Chef shelf and I don't have to open the smoker door or even put my beer down except to swap pellets and maybe tweak the temp dial a hair.

This was a HUGE upgrade from my $80 smoker that didn't go above 220 and my "instant read thermometer" that took about 30 seconds to register.
 

jonKranked

Detective Dookie
Nov 10, 2005
86,058
24,587
media blackout
Fancy wireless meat thermometer. I think I spent $70 including the Camp Chef shelf and I don't have to open the smoker door or even put my beer down except to swap pellets and maybe tweak the temp dial a hair.

This was a HUGE upgrade from my $80 smoker that didn't go above 220 and my "instant read thermometer" that took about 30 seconds to register.
got it. hard pass.
 

jimmydean

The Official Meat of Ridemonkey
Sep 10, 2001
41,266
13,383
Portland, OR
got it. hard pass.
Yeah, if your door temp is consistent and you are only cooking one thing, it doesn't make sense. I don't use the probe for ribs, but brisket and prime rib worked very well and the ambient temp is easier to Reed than my door gauge. Plus I am lazy. :rofl:
 

jonKranked

Detective Dookie
Nov 10, 2005
86,058
24,587
media blackout
Yeah, if your door temp is consistent and you are only cooking one thing, it doesn't make sense. I don't use the probe for ribs, but brisket and prime rib worked very well and the ambient temp is easier to Reed than my door gauge. Plus I am lazy. :rofl:
i just have a weber propane grill. not much benefit for me tbh. unless ghetto smoking a pork shoulder or something, but for that i'd probably put it on the rotisserie
 

dan-o

Turbo Monkey
Jun 30, 2004
6,499
2,805
Just peruse Redfin in Detroit.

Lots of $500 burned out homes.
In Detroit it’s just sport.
Growing up there I always thought Devils Night, the night before Halloween when arson is turned to 11, was a national thing.
Then I moved away and learned otherwise.
That was a letdown.
 

slyfink

Turbo Monkey
Sep 16, 2008
9,350
5,100
Ottawa, Canada
Today was the first day of Camp Dad for my boys. I am now at the hospital with one of them.

He fell off a play structure at the playground and hurt his arm. Sounds like he sprained his elbow. I hope that's it. Kinda throws my plans to bike, paddle and go to the aerial park out the window...
 

jdcamb

Tool Time!
Feb 17, 2002
19,849
8,453
Nowhere Man!
In Detroit it’s just sport.
Growing up there I always thought Devils Night, the night before Halloween when arson is turned to 11, was a national thing.
Then I moved away and learned otherwise.
That was a letdown.
We had Devils night in Buffalo also. I used to stay in Detroit a lot in the 90's. It was Devils Night every night.
 

SkaredShtles

Michael Bolton
Sep 21, 2003
65,830
12,827
In a van.... down by the river
Today was the first day of Camp Dad for my boys. I am now at the hospital with one of them.

He fell off a play structure at the playground and hurt his arm. Sounds like he sprained his elbow. I hope that's it. Kinda throws my plans to bike, paddle and go to the aerial park out the window...
You know what would help that? Moar kids. :p
 

jdcamb

Tool Time!
Feb 17, 2002
19,849
8,453
Nowhere Man!
May have found a new place. Its out in the woods. Cheap. Trails and water nearby. My own land to garden and care for. Solar system and woodstove. Well water.