[lanman]

Hey guys, every time I downstroke on my non-drive side pedal, it clicks or makes some sort of creaking noise. I have tried to tighten it but it seems to be tightened all the way. What could be the problem??

 

[LoboDelFuego]

If you tightened it all the way, you may have stripped it. Or, it may just be the bearings, which you can fix with grease. If this doesn't help, it may be your crankset.

 

[oldfart]

Oh man, it could be a lot of things. Could be crank spindle connection, cleats, bottom bracket, ring bolts or even pedals. Try taking things apart cleaning and regreasing, one bit at a time until it goes away.