Quantcast

2010 DHR or 2011 demo?

quickneonrt

Turbo Monkey
Apr 8, 2003
1,611
0
Staten Island NY
currently on a 2010 Glory but am looking for something else. I like it but don't love it. I am looking to buy end of this season October.

I have narrowed it down to the 2011 demo 8 or Turner DHR DW. I realize very few if anyone has time on these bikes but I am going to throw it out there.
 

bikesair

Chimp
Jun 30, 2009
67
0
San Luis Obispo CA
currently on a 2010 Glory but am looking for something else. I like it but don't love it. I am looking to buy end of this season October.

I have narrowed it down to the 2011 demo 8 or Turner DHR DW. I realize very few if anyone has time on these bikes but I am going to throw it out there.
I think a lot more thought has been put into the DHR, on both DW's side and Turners side. The Demo and the Turner both have very stiff rear ends and a very low center of gravity so they are pretty equal in that sense. I just think that Dave Weagle has a little more understanding of suspension linkages than anyone else in the industry. Thats just my opinion though. I have yet to ride one. I ride Meastro.
 

bikesair

Chimp
Jun 30, 2009
67
0
San Luis Obispo CA
I don't think I'm the only one that thinks this. I feel a good comparison is a company like Avalanche. It's one company perfecting one aspect of a mountain bike. DW is kind of the same thing except he also works with the manufacturers. I would assume less compromises are made during manufacturing/design but that's just a guess.
 

quickneonrt

Turbo Monkey
Apr 8, 2003
1,611
0
Staten Island NY
not digging the whole bb30 thing on the Demo. I have had several fsr bikes 03 bighit, 04 demo9, 07 sxt, 09 demo7 and they have gotten better over the years but the dw link on the sunday and ibis bikes are really nice also.
 

quickneonrt

Turbo Monkey
Apr 8, 2003
1,611
0
Staten Island NY
I think a lot more thought has been put into the DHR, on both DW's side and Turners side. The Demo and the Turner both have very stiff rear ends and a very low center of gravity so they are pretty equal in that sense. I just think that Dave Weagle has a little more understanding of suspension linkages than anyone else in the industry. Thats just my opinion though. I have yet to ride one. I ride Meastro.
humm Specialized stole and has been working on the fsr/horst link much longer then Dave has been thinking of suspension designs.
 

Santa Maria

Monkey
Aug 29, 2007
653
0
Austria
I think a lot more thought has been put into the DHR, on both DW's side and Turners side. The Demo and the Turner both have very stiff rear ends and a very low center of gravity so they are pretty equal in that sense. I just think that Dave Weagle has a little more understanding of suspension linkages than anyone else in the industry. Thats just my opinion though. I have yet to ride one. I ride Meastro.
if you compare the DW Sunday and Giant Glory (speaking of the pre 2010 version) the Glory felt way better suspension wise......
 

dw

Wiffle Ball ninja
Sep 10, 2001
2,943
0
MV
if you compare the DW Sunday and Giant Glory (speaking of the pre 2010 version) the Glory felt way better suspension wise......
I'm curious, how exactly did the bikes compare?

What spring rates, dampers and suspension settings were you using on both bikes? What tires and pressures were you using? What were the riding conditions during your comparative tests? Were you doing back to back testing over a period of days or is this a comparison over years?
 
Last edited:

ianjenn

Turbo Monkey
Sep 12, 2006
3,001
704
SLO
I had a Sunday for about 6 months. The bike pedaled and cornered very well. I have had multiple FSR bikes over the years. Both suspension systems work and do feel very different out on the trail.

I do sort of agree with an earlier poster saying Specialized SORT OF (not paid enough) hahah, stole the design off AMP. I would not pay $6K for a complete bike made oversees. Basically I'm saying hey Specialized I like you so much that the extra $1000 you make from building stuff over there is a tip.

I already ordered my DHR BTW.......
 
Last edited:

bizutch

Delicate CUSTOM flower
Dec 11, 2001
15,929
24
Over your shoulder whispering
I had a Sunday for about 6 months. The bike pedaled and cornered very well. I have had multiple FSR bikes over the years. Both suspension systems work and do feel very different out on the trail.

I do sort of agree with an earlier poster saying Specialized stole the design off AMP. I would not pay $6K for a complete bike made oversees. Basically I'm saying hey Specialized I like you so much that the extra $1000 you make from building stuff over there is a tip.
Not correct. Dave Turner himself will even tell you that.



As for riding both, I've spent an entire season on an '06 Demo (with Double Barrel setup specifically for it by the factory, but the mechanics and suspension of the Demo have been redesigned and tweeked a bit since then, so I can't compare both apples to apples.

What I do have is input on is the general riding characteristics of both style pivots. I've spent one season on an Enduro trail bike and Demo (2006)and currently ride a FSR link Turner 5 Pack. I raced a full season on a decked out, properly tuned Iron Horse Sunday (2007) as well.

In '08, I had no personal bike but got to race on a Morewood Izumi and GT DHi and enjoyed them as well. But all of these designs, while setup for me and my racing style, each reacted in completely different ways to the rider.

The FSR is always very active and pedaling is neutral across the board. The GT is a sprinters dream come true, the Morewood sprints great and is fun to play on. The Sunday, oddly enough, pedals really well too, but better than the other designs in medium sized rocks and roots, where either the FSR becomes a vague input or you get feedback from the other designs.

Now, the most important piece of info. I got to put in a full weekend of riding on the new DW-DHR design and can say that so far, it does more for the rider than all the other designs.

You can feel the rear end take a hit and not lose momentum, but continue forward. And rider input at the pedal produces a distinct forward movement without excess bob or pedal kickback. There's a sense of acceleration in terrain where typically you can feel yourself hanging up or losing speed.

I'm on a perfectly dialed '09 DHR and it's a World Cup pinner of a bike. The new DW-DHR is an easy to feel advantage over it though and any of the other bikes I've ridden, including the Sunday of similar design.
 
Last edited:

dw

Wiffle Ball ninja
Sep 10, 2001
2,943
0
MV
Ok insignificant discrepancy, on the website it says 2010 and they are finally coming out.
I know, it was my lame attempt as matter-of-fact humor. As you can see I'm not very good at it :) hah

Dave, why should I choose the DHR over the 2011 Demo and the 2010 Glory I already have?
I could go on and on about the technical attributes that make up the dw-DHR for sure. I have not ridden a 2011 Demo, so despite having my preconceptions, I can't really comment.

Here's what I can tell you about the DHR, as I've got 5 solid days of testing under my belt now. It's a race bike through and through. Sure it's a lot of fun to ride, but it really begs to be ridden hard. If you are the type of rider who will push hard in every corner, ride aggressively, you lean and drift your way down the hill, this bike is probably right up your alley. If you are a sport class rider who goes out to bash with his buddies once a month (maybe), I'm not sure that you will appreciate the bike for what it is. Keep in mind that we've pushed the geometry as slack and low as we could, and because of the dw-link, the reality is that we can go slacker and lower than other designs. This isn't just some BS or spew on a messageboard. It's an application of real science, and I kid you not that I can throw in pedal strokes at will on this bike, despite a 13.4 BB height. Head angle sits at 63ish, which is on the slacker side, but it doesn't rake out under power like some other bikes.

The only way that you are going to know if you like it is if you ride the bike and be honest with yourself about how you are going to use it. This bike has been bred to be a tool for racing and you can feel it in the ride.
 

zdubyadubya

Turbo Monkey
Apr 13, 2008
1,273
96
Ellicott City, MD
not digging the whole bb30 thing on the Demo.
:confused: huh?

why? it doesn't force you to use certain cranks. in fact you can use any crank system you please. your options are limitless. whats not to dig? bb shell is bigger as well which translates to a stiffer frame and better power/energy transfer. methinks you might not fully understand what exactly they did with their bb on that bike.... there is literally NO drawback to this design that I can think of...

and btw, my vote goes for demo. after watching the fiasco that occurred with the first production run revolts i would avoid any first production run bike. is the dhr hot? god yes... is it reliable? will it crack in unforseen places? will it have funky hardware issues? nobody knows because the number of bikes in the wild being ridden by privateers is so low. you can do all the FEM you want, it doesn't substitute for real world testing.
 

Santa Maria

Monkey
Aug 29, 2007
653
0
Austria
I'm curious, how exactly did the bikes compare?

What spring rates, dampers and suspension settings were you using on both bikes? What tires and pressures were you using? What were the riding conditions during your comparative tests? Were you doing back to back testing over a period of days or is this a comparison over years?
I rode a sunday for nearly 3 seasons, my riding budy had an 08 Glory, both on DHX 5.0s and Boxxer WCs, besides Stem und Bars the same components, more or less same weight as well......

We switched bikes now and then and the Giant felt better suspension wise IMO. I wouldn' have traded the sunday for a glory though.

Over all there are a lot of great frames out there and i would not by a frame only because of a the suspension design....
 

captainspauldin

intrigued by a pole
May 14, 2007
1,263
177
Jersey Shore
and btw, my vote goes for demo. after watching the fiasco that occurred with the first production run revolts i would avoid any first production run bike. is the dhr hot? god yes... is it reliable? will it crack in unforseen places? will it have funky hardware issues? nobody knows because the number of bikes in the wild being ridden by privateers is so low. you can do all the FEM you want, it doesn't substitute for real world testing.
I think you're forgetting that the '11 Demo is first production run of the new design.. I would say that you're running the "First Production" risk on either bike. Turner does have a very good reputation for taking care of their customers, not saying the Big S doesn't.. DT just has a reputation of standing behind his bikes even if they've been altered(I recall reading threads on DT warrantying "drilled" older style DHRs), can't say the same for Specialized in that sense.

Personally it would be a hard decision for me, I would probably go w/the demo based on my LBS carrying Specialized and my bank account. Without those 2 factors, I would no doubt go w/the dw-DHR..
 

quickneonrt

Turbo Monkey
Apr 8, 2003
1,611
0
Staten Island NY
Thanks Bizutch that is an answer am looking for. I have always ridden Specialized 03 bighit dh, 04 Demo9, 07 SXT and 09 Demo7 w/fox 40. This year I have been riding a Glory and it is very different the one thing I don't like is the occasional pedal feedback.
 
Last edited:

Inclag

Turbo Monkey
Sep 9, 2001
2,752
442
MA
The finish, manufacturing processes, and durability of the demo line is hard for any manufacturer to compete against, let alone one with limited capabilities such as Turner. Both companies have incredible support.

I know for me all of these are a factor for me so it would be Demo hands down.

Really though, there's something to be said about riding a bike that fits you most comfortably too. It all depends on your priorities. Bikes are rad, you'll probably be stoked either way.
 

William42

fork ways
Jul 31, 2007
3,936
680
without ever having ridden either bike, and having literally no idea how they ride, I would hands down say a tricycle. Bikes are outdated and overrated.
 

bullcrew

3 Dude Approved
I know, it was my lame attempt as matter-of-fact humor. As you can see I'm not very good at it :) hah



I could go on and on about the technical attributes that make up the dw-DHR for sure. I have not ridden a 2011 Demo, so despite having my preconceptions, I can't really comment.

Here's what I can tell you about the DHR, as I've got 5 solid days of testing under my belt now. It's a race bike through and through. Sure it's a lot of fun to ride, but it really begs to be ridden hard. If you are the type of rider who will push hard in every corner, ride aggressively, you lean and drift your way down the hill, this bike is probably right up your alley. If you are a sport class rider who goes out to bash with his buddies once a month (maybe), I'm not sure that you will appreciate the bike for what it is. Keep in mind that we've pushed the geometry as slack and low as we could, and because of the dw-link, the reality is that we can go slacker and lower than other designs. This isn't just some BS or spew on a messageboard. It's an application of real science, and I kid you not that I can throw in pedal strokes at will on this bike, despite a 13.4 BB height. Head angle sits at 63ish, which is on the slacker side, but it doesn't rake out under power like some other bikes.

The only way that you are going to know if you like it is if you ride the bike and be honest with yourself about how you are going to use it. This bike has been bred to be a tool for racing and you can feel it in the ride.
Hey thats from the extenze commercial D, whatcha working on now!!;)
 

MDJ

Monkey
Dec 15, 2005
669
0
San Jose, CA
I love it how everyone compares a 2010 or 2011 bike with a competing brand from 2006 and, surprise, finds the new one better. :rofl:
 

W4S

Turbo Monkey
Mar 2, 2004
1,282
23
Back in Hell A, b1thces
humm Specialized stole and has been working on the fsr/horst link much longer then Dave has been thinking of suspension designs.
You do know the Dave Turner worked with Horst Leitner on the FSR link at specialized, right? and that turners ran horst links until 2007?

Turner Suspension Bicycles - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia@@AMEPARAM@@/wiki/File:Turner_Logo.gif" class="image"><img alt="Turner Logo.gif" src="http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/8/8d/Turner_Logo.gif/250px-Turner_Logo.gif"@@AMEPARAM@@en/thumb/8/8d/Turner_Logo.gif/250px-Turner_Logo.gif

i think both bikes will be great, i'd take either one and be happy.
 

bizutch

Delicate CUSTOM flower
Dec 11, 2001
15,929
24
Over your shoulder whispering
I love it how everyone compares a 2010 or 2011 bike with a competing brand from 2006 and, surprise, finds the new one better. :rofl:
I'm currently riding an FSR suspended bike and have ridden several renditions of the FSR. While you can adjust the way the suspension reacts in certain manners, you still have to stay within it's limits and there is a VERY distinct ride characteristic to the FSR design regardless of the model year.

Do you own one or have you ridden it in it's different variations? If you have, post your thoughts. It's an open forum.:thumb:
 

MDJ

Monkey
Dec 15, 2005
669
0
San Jose, CA
I'm currently riding an FSR suspended bike and have ridden several renditions of the FSR. While you can adjust the way the suspension reacts in certain manners, you still have to stay within it's limits and there is a VERY distinct ride characteristic to the FSR design regardless of the model year.

Do you own one or have you ridden it in it's different variations? If you have, post your thoughts. It's an open forum.:thumb:
BTW, my comment wasn't directed specifically at you although I know it sounded like it.

When the Sunday was king, it was king for a reason. However, things progress I would definitely take a 2011 Demo over an older Sunday. I would also take a 2011 DW Turner over a 2006 Demo. Now, a 2011 Demo or 2011 Turner? Both please.

My first FSR among many was an AMP and I currently have an '06 SX Trail, '07 SX, and '09 Demo. I have owned and/or ridden DW link bikes and quite a few other designs over the years. Each one has + and -, and each design has gotten better over ther years. Am I a Specialize/FSR fanboy? Not really, just circumstances more than anything. I can get along with most designs these days. It's not like in the old days when you couldn't compete unless you had an M-1.

Remember the first VPP? Well, what Intense and SC are doing is a wee bit better than back then I think. My point is that it isn't fair to compare a new design with an old design, especially when geometry, shock design, components and other things affect the ride along with the actual suspension design.

Bottom line - the 2011 Demo and 2011 DW Turner will be two of the best bikes out there (along with a couple others) so you can't go wrong.
 

time-bomb

Monkey
May 2, 2008
957
21
right here -> .
BTW, my comment wasn't directed specifically at you although I know it sounded like it.

When the Sunday was king, it was king for a reason. However, things progress I would definitely take a 2011 Demo over an older Sunday. I would also take a 2011 DW Turner over a 2006 Demo. Now, a 2011 Demo or 2011 Turner? Both please.

My first FSR among many was an AMP and I currently have an '06 SX Trail, '07 SX, and '09 Demo. I have owned and/or ridden DW link bikes and quite a few other designs over the years. Each one has + and -, and each design has gotten better over ther years. Am I a Specialize/FSR fanboy? Not really, just circumstances more than anything. I can get along with most designs these days. It's not like in the old days when you couldn't compete unless you had an M-1.

Remember the first VPP? Well, what Intense and SC are doing is a wee bit better than back then I think. My point is that it isn't fair to compare a new design with an old design, especially when geometry, shock design, components and other things affect the ride along with the actual suspension design.

Bottom line - the 2011 Demo and 2011 DW Turner will be two of the best bikes out there (along with a couple others) so you can't go wrong.
I fully endorse this sentiment :thumb:

OP - flip a coin, heads you win, tails you win! Good luck!