Quantcast

This is what's wrong with The Industry™

ChrisRobin

Turbo Monkey
Jan 30, 2002
3,409
212
Vancouver
yeah; something like a marsh guard looks fine, but a more substantial bolt on (like factory fox fenders, which i run full time) appear to be no bueno. bit of an oversight, i'd say.

Yeeeeah... so much for my Mudhugger fender and my hard-to-find bolt on adapter for it.
 

Westy

the teste
Nov 22, 2002
56,226
22,259
Sleazattle
yeah; something like a marsh guard looks fine, but a more substantial bolt on (like factory fox fenders, which i run full time) appear to be no bueno. bit of an oversight, i'd say.


Such a good idea. I am sure people will use that just like they do the carry on bag sizers in airports.
 

vivisectxi

Monkey
Jan 14, 2021
521
626
yeast van
yeah, first lift shenanigans should be entertaining. cutting off zip tied fenders is no big thang, but you need a socket & micro a/k to pull a fox, and what, you didn't bring bleed valve washers with you?? guess a fender removal station will be the next thing.
 

canadmos

Cake Tease
May 29, 2011
22,208
21,801
Canaderp
I just read that instagram post by Whistler Bike Park. Basically says "some fenders will work, some won't. If yours doesn't, go buy a different one". LOL.

This was added on Pinkbike. Looks like those two flared bumpers are what your fork is supposed to rest one. Meanwhile this person's bike is resting on the fender:

in North Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada - photo by leelau - Pinkbike
That design is supposed to work by letting your fork touch the rack? :|

I don't care what those bumpers are made of, it could be cashmere goats ass hair, there ain't no way that won't scratch up your lowers.

The park here has similar trays, but your bike simply hangs from the wheel and clears any fender. The wheel tips a bit, but no part of the fork or anything touches it*.


*not supposed to anyways, I scratched my brand new fork on one, that has wider trays and allows the front wheel to flop over a few inches more.

Now is Chris Kovariks chance to make custom bolt on fenders that are Whitler lift approved™. The STFU Guard, if you will.
 

ChrisRobin

Turbo Monkey
Jan 30, 2002
3,409
212
Vancouver
I'm not sure what that rack is supposed to do. Based on the video I posted, the weight of the bike rests on the fender which makes contact with the rack. Take the fender off, it looks like the fork would rest on those bumpers. I'm sure by tonight there will be more on this.
 

trib

not worthy of a Rux.
Jun 22, 2009
1,674
684
IMG_5242.jpeg
That design is supposed to work by letting your fork touch the rack? :|

I don't care what those bumpers are made of, it could be cashmere goats ass hair, there ain't no way that won't scratch up your lowers.

The park here has similar trays, but your bike simply hangs from the wheel and clears any fender. The wheel tips a bit, but no part of the fork or anything touches it*.


*not supposed to anyways, I scratched my brand new fork on one, that has wider trays and allows the front wheel to flop over a few inches more.

Now is Chris Kovariks chance to make custom bolt on fenders that are Whitler lift approved™. The STFU Guard, if you will.
THE fenders are so back.
 

daisycutter

Turbo Monkey
Apr 8, 2006
1,695
190
New York City
yeah; something like a marsh guard looks fine, but a more substantial bolt on (like factory fox fenders, which i run full time) appear to be no bueno. bit of an oversight, i'd say.

They had these types of racks at Windham Bike Park in New York last year. It was not an issue at all, the weight of the bike pulled the top clamp down and held the hundreds of bikes securely last summer.
 
Last edited:

trib

not worthy of a Rux.
Jun 22, 2009
1,674
684
THE, the most SEO-unoptimized brand name of all time.


Business bro: Uh, I’d like to trademark my brand name.

USPTO: That’s sick bro, what is your company called?

Bro: It’s called the.

USPTO: …
I had to search “Toby Henderson enterprise mud fender” to find the beautiful example above
 

HardtailHack

used an iron once
Jan 20, 2009
7,914
7,330
Got the old man's wet weather sled in for some new bits.
New BB, went up to a 10sp drivetrain, new shifters, road cass, all new brakes and then I'll be doing all new brakes again because it seems Clarks re-badged some bottom of the barrel junk that is worse than entry level crap that was already on the bike.
Will get some Avid SD brakes.
IMG_20240518_165353.jpg

Oops, wrong thread, but the shitty brakes sorta make it the right thread.
 
Last edited:

scrublover

Turbo Monkey
Sep 1, 2004
3,281
7,096
Got the old man's wet weather sled in for some new bits.
New BB, went up to a 10sp drivetrain, new shifters, road cass, all new brakes and then I'll be doing all new brakes again because it seems Clarks re-badged some bottom of the barrel junk that is worse than entry level crap that was already on the bike.
Will get some Avid SD brakes.
View attachment 211960
Oops, wrong thread, but the shitty brakes sorta make it the right thread.
You've got a fender on there. That works.

Solid townie/commuter!
 

HardtailHack

used an iron once
Jan 20, 2009
7,914
7,330
You've got a fender on there. That works.

Solid townie/commuter!
Yeah it came with fenders, from memory the bike was maybe 350 Aussie dollars.
The wheels didn't last long, it started snapping spokes pretty early on, for some reason the spokes were bottomed out in the nipples from new.
It has served him well, all it needs now is the XT freehub serviced(tool ordered) and it brakes a bit funny up front as he got a dent in the rim when he tried to stop a motorbike that was zooming along a bike path, haha!
It's horrible to ride with the seat back that far but you can't tell old people what to do.
 

Leafy

Monkey
Sep 13, 2019
647
412
A couple of the bike parts near me have those new fangled self load/unload bike mounts on the lifts and they're no issue for zip tie fenders or the bolt on fox38 fender from fox (even on littler 27.5 wheels). Maybe the extra long fox one would be a problem.
 

SkullCrack

Monkey
Sep 3, 2004
710
145
PNW
THE, the most SEO-unoptimized brand name of all time.


Business bro: Uh, I’d like to trademark my brand name.

USPTO: That’s sick bro, what is your company called?

Bro: It’s called the.

USPTO: …
He only tried a little harder with his next company: Box

 

ChrisRobin

Turbo Monkey
Jan 30, 2002
3,409
212
Vancouver
A couple of the bike parts near me have those new fangled self load/unload bike mounts on the lifts and they're no issue for zip tie fenders or the bolt on fox38 fender from fox (even on littler 27.5 wheels). Maybe the extra long fox one would be a problem.
I think it all depends on how long your bike is, how big your wheels are...etc. If you have a large DH bike 29/29 for example, I figure your back wheel will rest against the bottom bar before your fender gets crushed. Some people reporting their fenders are fine, and some others aren't. That's too bad... what a pain:
 

Attachments

Leafy

Monkey
Sep 13, 2019
647
412
My tiny old gambler didnt have an issue, nor my wife and my normal sized medium trail bikes, or her medium nomad. Must just be a tall people problem.
 

6thElement

Schrodinger's Immigrant
Jul 29, 2008
17,414
14,904
Looks like the 6 pack lift at Big Sky, no issue with zip tied fenders on our DH bikes a couple of summers ago when we visited.
 

buckoW

Turbo Monkey
Mar 1, 2007
3,839
4,881
Champery, Switzerland
The ones the lift company recently installed in Champery needed a bunch of adjustments to make room for fenders and keep the rear tire off the ground on XXL frames. The rear tire holder needed to be angled rearward as much as possible.

1716088455495.jpeg
 

Jm_

sled dog's bollocks
Jan 14, 2002
20,382
10,853
AK
The ones the lift company recently installed in Champery needed a bunch of adjustments to make room for fenders and keep the rear tire off the ground on XXL frames. The rear tire holder needed to be angled rearward as much as possible.

View attachment 212001
Pretty sure that's what our local hill has now. They have a static one for practice, but these are fairly impractical for a lot of riders to loft the bike up onto, they just aren't ready for the movement. Liftees do it mostly.
 

sethimus

neu bizutch
Feb 5, 2006
5,378
2,457
not in Whistler anymore :/
i liked those in the fai zone in paganella. you put your bikes on by yourself, and on the top station, the car with the bikes decouples from the transport mechanism and stops, so when you arrive you take your own bikes off again. no need for lifties.
 

Lelandjt

adorbs
Apr 4, 2008
2,647
1,003
Breckenridge, CO/Lahaina,HI
I'll be adding Fox bleeder washers to my toolbox this season. It sucks that you can't remove the fender without replacing it with washers. Twice I've gone to Crested Butte and forgotten that their lift doesn't work with Fox fenders. You have to tell the lifty each time so they set your bike on a chair instead of using the rack. Sounds like this will become more common.
 

ChrisRobin

Turbo Monkey
Jan 30, 2002
3,409
212
Vancouver
There are a bunch of videos up that show when you load your front wheel into the rack, the back wheel just rolls on the platform until the chair clears said platform. Then your bike 'swings' down until the back wheel hits and rests against the lower bar - that's when your fender can get crushed.

I'll have to pick up one of those marshguard fenders locally just in case I have to make a parking lot fender change. I'm betting the Whistler shops are selling those like crazy... and charging a lot.
 
Last edited:

canadmos

Cake Tease
May 29, 2011
22,208
21,801
Canaderp
It's weird that these type of racks are getting popular at the exact same time as the type of fenders they don't work with. Neither was common 4 years ago.
It's that particular kind of rack though.

These ones from leitnerpoma (sp?) don't come close to majority of fenders.

Though looking how they all work, alot of this shit could be avoided if the lower bar was set "out" further.

These are the trays our local hill uses. Never heard of someone's fender being an issue....they don't even have side racks.



MOAR shimz is the answer, as always.
 
Last edited:

Lelandjt

adorbs
Apr 4, 2008
2,647
1,003
Breckenridge, CO/Lahaina,HI
Maybe not in the land of sunshine and dust.
Mudhugger style front mudguards became popular here well over a decade ago
That's not the type of fender that's the problem. It's the new bolt on fenders for Fox & Rockshox. Fox being the worst cuz you can't just unbolt it. You need to replace it with a set of specific plastic washers.
 
Last edited:

Gary

my pronouns are hag/gis
Aug 27, 2002
8,594
6,495
UK
Why can't you just leave the screw holes empty? Genuine question, I'm not doubting on your statement, I'm just puzzled on how could Fox do something so stupid...
explains it

I don't really see why bolt on mudguards are an issue but the ziptied ones aren't. Bearing in mind they're shaped the same and sit in pretty much an identical position. Plus some of the ziptie guards are a good bit longer.

eg. Mudhugger long

RRP Proguard max
 

Lelandjt

adorbs
Apr 4, 2008
2,647
1,003
Breckenridge, CO/Lahaina,HI
Why can't you just leave the screw holes empty? Genuine question, I'm not doubting on your statement, I'm just puzzled on how could Fox do something so stupid...
There are 2 small screw holes on the arch, those are just left empty. The fender also attaches by the bleeder buttons going through 2 holes in the fender. When you unscrew the bleeders and remove the fender they can't be screwed back in without adding plastic washers that replace the thickness of the fender tabs. I tried and it leaks oil.
They could have designed the fender to come on & off with an allen wrench. Instead you need to bring a crescent wrench and the washers. It doesn't seem like they intended it to be frequently taken on & off, which seems kinda the opposite of how a lot of people would like to use it. This new thing of needing to remove it at some bike parks just makes it worse.
 
Last edited:

Lelandjt

adorbs
Apr 4, 2008
2,647
1,003
Breckenridge, CO/Lahaina,HI
explains it

I don't really see why bolt on mudguards are an issue but the ziptied ones aren't. Bearing in mind they're shaped the same and sit in pretty much an identical position. Plus some of the ziptie guards are a good bit longer.

eg. Mudhugger long

RRP Proguard max
Those would be a problem on the Crested Butte lift. The ones that aren't a problem are the Marsh Guard type, because of their size and flexibility.